修習底德《伯羅奔尼撒戰爭史》的 χάρις
Χάρις in Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War
國立中正大學歷史系(Department of History, National Chung Cheng University)
摘要
本文以修習底德《伯羅奔尼撒戰爭史》為文本分析χάρις的意義。χάρις是古希臘城邦外交與個人跨社會互動可選擇建立的重要關係,但尚未得到學者足夠重視。本文發現χάρις五個特性:首先,χάρις是專有名詞,指涉特定施恩與受惠關係。其次,在χάρις關係中,施恩者與受惠者的不平等是有限不平等,既非絕對也非固定不變。第三,χάρις有好壞之辯;有正義也有可恥的χάρις。第四,在χάρις關係中信用問題相形重要。最後,χάρις的不平等關係與民主平等原則有一定程度衝突。本文同時說明χάρις關係各方複雜互動;古希臘人擅長操作χάρις遊戲規則,爭取最佳利益。
Abstract
This paper examines the meaning of χάρις in Thucydides’ <i>History of the Peloponnesian War</i>. χάρις is a technical term that describes the important relationships the ancient Greeks could choose to build when developing city-states diplomacy as well as interpersonal and cross-societal interactions. However, the relationships that χάρις characterizes have not yet received signigicant scholarly attention. As such, this article presents and explores five main features of χάρις. Firstly, χάρις is a proper noun that indicates a specific reciprocal relationship between the benefactor and the beneficiary. Secondly, the inequality inherent in χάρις between the benefactor and the beneficiary is temporary rather than absolute and permanent. Thirdly, while χάρις encompasses both positive and negative reciprocities, it emphasizes disputes over justice, the common good, and unrighteousness. Fourthly, the notion of trust and credibility in χάρις is more important and more critical as compared to other reciprocal relationships. Lastly, the term χάρις is negatively perceived in the domestic affairs of Athens when its inequality contradicts the equalitarian principle of Athenian Democracy. This paper explicates the complex forms of interactions from multiple χάρις-relations and argues that the ancient Greeks’ proficiency in manipulating the set of rules of χάρις results in their pursuit of best interests.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 103期
- 出版
- 2025年05月
- 頁碼
- 153–185
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007906
同期目錄
- 重探「近思錄,四子之階梯」簡逸光(Chien, I-kuang)・頁 1–40
- 方以智對西方天文學的接受、反省及其時代意義李忠達(Lee, Chung-ta)・頁 41–76
- 近代日本臨濟宗及曹洞宗的禪學論爭:以《禪道》及《達磨禪》兩雜誌的考察為中心張崑將(Chang, Kun-chiang)・頁 77–108
- 《春秋》、《左傳》中的 「及」和「與」游文福(Yew, Boon-hock)・頁 109–151
- 修習底德《伯羅奔尼撒戰爭史》的 χάρις黃俊龍(Ng, Chun-liong)・頁 153–185