美與真之間:馬里旦與吉爾松的論辯
Beauty and Truth: The Argument between Jacques Maritain and Etienne Gilson
輔仁大學天主教學術研究院助理研究員
(Assistant Research Fellow, Fu Jen Academia Catholica, Fu Jen Catholic University)
摘要
馬里旦和吉爾松是同一個時代的人,他們來自同一個國家,分享著相同的信仰以及哲學傳統,然而兩人對於藝術的看法在某些點上卻是完全對立的,其差異產生的原因,值得我們仔細地探討。本文的主要目的,是希望從美與真、藝術與知識之間的論辯入手,逐步勾勒出馬里旦與吉爾松這兩位優秀的天主教哲學家在思考美術問題上所顯現的差異。並進一步在理解其差異後,體認到兩人關於美術的不同看法,與其說是某種對立或不相容的衝突,不如說是他們從不同的角度切入美術問題而揭露出關於美、關於美術所展現的不同面向與意義。
Abstract
Jacques Maritain and Etienne Gilson, despise the fact that they came from the same country, shared the same religious beliefs and belonged to the same philosophical school (Neo-Thomism), expressed opposite opinions towards certain points in fine arts. It is worth the effort to find out why and how this controversy appeared because their views help us to see a deeper meaning of art.
This paper starts with illustrating Maritain and Gilson’s respective views on fine arts. Through discerning the boundary between beauty and truth, art and knowledge, this paper presents the key points of their arguments. After realizing why and how the conflict arose, this paper offers a different view on truth concerning art, and also shows that the disagreements between Maritain and Gilson may not be treated as an uncompromising conflict; rather, these two philosophers simply dealt with fine arts from different perspectives and thereby demonstrated respective aspects and meaning about art and fine arts.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 78期
- 出版
- 2013年05月
- 頁碼
- 143–163
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008030
同期目錄
- 《紅樓夢》中的情∕欲論述──以「才子佳人模式」之反思為中心歐麗娟(Ou, Li-chuan)・頁 1–43
- 華語語系的跨國連結:臺灣-馬華文學詹閔旭(Zhan, Min-xu)・頁 45–74
- 朝向「後人類詩」──陳克華詩的科幻視域劉正忠(Liu, Cheng-chung)・頁 75–116
- 論西田幾多郎中期「絕對無」的意義 ──以〈叡智的世界〉為線索黃文宏(Huang, Wen-hong)・頁 117–142
- 美與真之間:馬里旦與吉爾松的論辯何佳瑞(Katia Lenehan)・頁 143–163
- 器樂曲的「兩個事實」:Franz Brendel的標題音樂美學劉彥玲(Annie Yen-ling Liu)・頁 165–208
- 女性口舌病原論:診斷《馬克白》林熒嬌(Lin, Ying-chiao)・頁 209–236
- 蘇珊.葛列絲貝的《瑣事》與《女性的名譽》中的地方與性別施懿芹(Shih, Yi-chin)・頁 237–256