《聊齋誌異》悍妒書寫的複調話語及其性別意蘊
The Polyphony and Gender Implications of the écriture en Virago in Liaozhai zhiyi
國立臺灣大學中國文學系(Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University)
摘要
《聊齋誌異》不僅探奇誌異,也網羅世情,全書近三分之一篇幅攸關婚戀主題,對女性悍妒現象尤有豐富的關注。無論從傳統性別語境或蒲松齡一己遭際的悍婦經驗考察,悍妒婦女都是被貶抑批判甚至否定的對象;然而從性別角度觀照,《聊齋》的悍妒書寫展現悍妒婦女依違游移父權體制之間的生存經驗及細緻的生命紋理,在作者主觀意旨之外,蘊涵了繁複的聲口及話語。本文參酌巴赫金(Ъахтинг,Михаил МихаЙлович)的小說理論,剖析《聊齋》婚姻情境中的悍妒書寫,側重從傳統父權機制的縫隙中,細究《聊齋》如何揭顯女性的內在衝突與異質聲音,並尤重其間的動態辯證。論文涵括下列面向:一、乾綱/閫教的對立與游移,二、社會性別的框限與衝決,三、妻妾成群:妒情可憫、悍行可解?四、賢德悍妻:「暴力」之愛,五、重振乾綱與悍妒末路。
Abstract
Liaozhai zhiyi (Strange Tales from a Rustic Studio) is a work that explores not only the strangeness but also the ebb and flow of the mundane world. With themes related to marriage and love stories taking up nearly one-third of the book, Liaozhai zhiyi shows its specific concern for Viragoes. Either from the traditional gender context or from an encounter that Pu Songlin himself had, Viragoes are usually objects to be judged and blamed. However, if viewed from a gender perspective, the Viragoes in Liaozhai zhiyi have in fact presented the transgression and violation of patriarchalism. In addition to the intention of the author, in Liaozhai zhiyi we can surely ‘hear’ the intricate voices and discourse involved in the écriture en virago.
Therefore, this paper explores not only how Liaozhai zhiyi reveals heterogeneous voices and conflicts from the feminine stance but also how these voices form a dialectical dialogic interaction with traditional patriarchalism under the strong suppression of patriarchal society. To approach these issues, I focus on the écriture en virago in marital contexts with an eye on Mikhail M. Bakhtin’s theory of fiction. Specific concerns of this paper lie in the following aspects:
1. Conflicts and wavering between ethics for females in the patriarchal context and virago performances.
2. Framing and avulsion of gender borders
3. Roots of virago performances vs. polygamy
4. Virtuous viragoes with ‘forceful’ love
5. Revival of the patriarchal tradition and the epilog of the virago voices.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 76期
- 出版
- 2012年05月
- 頁碼
- 193–228
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008047
同期目錄
- 尊《序》?反《序》?──析論《毛詩李黃集解》的解《詩》立場黃忠慎(Huang, Chung-Shen)・頁 1–27
- 心學《易》中的陰陽與卜筮──以季本為核心賀廣如(Ho, Goang-ru)・頁 29–66
- 南朝「踞食論議」所反映儒、佛交涉的理論思維與文化意涵紀志昌(Chi, Chih-chang)・頁 67–105
- 李淵太原起兵的元從功臣──兼論楊隋之世的關隴集團伍伯常(NG Pak-sheung)・頁 107–157
- 《楚辭通釋》的楚辭學意義解讀──兼論其於船山詩學之位置吳旻旻(Wu, Min-min)・頁 159–192
- 《聊齋誌異》悍妒書寫的複調話語及其性別意蘊陳翠英(Chen, Chui-ying)・頁 193–228
- 林黛玉前期性格論──「真」與「率」的辨析與「個人主義」的反思歐麗娟(Ou, Li-chuan)・頁 229–264
- 英國思想界對里斯本大地震(1755)的回應陳正國(Chen, Jeng-guo)・頁 265–314
- 精神分析與政治哲學──佛洛依德,最後及最偉大的現代主義者李建漳(Lee, Chien-Chang)・頁 315–361