十六世紀末中韓使節關於陽明學的論辨及其意義──以許篈與袁黃為中心
Debates on Yang-ming Learning by Chinese and Korean Envoys in the Late Sixteenth Century and Their Significance: With Emphasis on Heo Bong and Yuan Huang
國立臺灣師範大學東亞文化暨發展學系(Department of East Asian Culture and Development, National Taiwan Normal University)
摘要
本文藉由考察兩段明朝與朝鮮政府派遣使節時,檢視陽明學在兩國之間所引起的爭議課題,從而看到陽明學在兩國使節之間所引起的波瀾現象。其一是以一五七四年朝鮮派遣許 (1551-1588)出使中國時,與中國士大夫筆談有關王陽明從祀的爭議問題;其二是一五九二年明朝政府派往支援朝鮮戰事的軍事參謀袁黃(1533-1606),因其毀朱衛王的態度而引起朝鮮群儒的爭議。本文藉由雙方異域的觀點與批判,以窺兩國知識人對陽明學的不同爭議,進一步探索陽明學在東亞的深刻意義。
Abstract
This paper will examine two controversies created by envoys from the Ming dynasty and from Joseon Korea by comparing the development of Yang-ming learning in each country. It will also illustrate the interactions concerning Yang-ming learning through envoys. The first controversy focused on Wang Yangming himself as he became an adjunct object of worship at the Confucian Temple. This occurred in 1547 when the Joseon envoy, Heo Bong (1551-1588), crossed swords with Chinese literati and scholar-officials over Wang’s part through written communication. The second controversy arose in 1592 when the Ming Dynasty sent a military staff officer, Yuan Huang (1533-1606), to advise Korea on her war against Japan. Yuan provoked a conflict with the Joseon Confucians by slandering Zhu Xi and defending Wang Yangming. This paper will examine the different arguments by intellectuals from both countries on Yang-ming learning. Moreover, the profound meaning of Yang-ming learning in East Asia will also be explored.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 70期
- 出版
- 2009年05月
- 頁碼
- 055–084
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008086
同期目錄
- 陰陽五行的階位秩序──董仲舒的天人哲學觀馮樹勳(Fung, Shu-fun)・頁 001–027
- 中古漢語時期漢文佛典的比擬式魏培泉(Wei, Pei-chuan)・頁 029–053
- 十六世紀末中韓使節關於陽明學的論辨及其意義──以許篈與袁黃為中心張崑將(Chang, Kun-chiang)・頁 055–084
- 論錢賓四先生之義理立場與其儒學觀戴景賢(Tai, Ching-hsien)・頁 085–111
- 光復初期臺大文學院的轉折與奠基莊長恭與傅斯年校長時期(1948.06-1950.12)李東華(Lee, Tong-hwa)・頁 113–144
- 褪去肉身的愛情──早期現代醫學文獻中愛情症的演化雷碧琦(Lei, Bi-qi Beatrice)・頁 145–178
- 宗教圖像爭議與路德教派文化政策——以紐倫堡接受宗教改革過程為中心的考察花亦芬(Hua, Yih-fen)・頁 179–229
- 理查.華格納的《精靈》探討張堯欽(Chang, Yau-chin)・頁 231–267
- 智性的陶塑──麥道爾《心靈與世界》中的自我林從一(Lin, Chung-i)・頁 269–289