從使役到條件
From Shi-yi Constructions to Conditionals
國立臺灣大學中國文學系(Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本文探討漢語使役動詞成為條件連詞的雙線發展:一線從命令義使役動詞虛化為條件連詞,文中以「使」和「令」的歷史發展為例說明;另一線從任由義使役動詞虛化為讓步條件連詞,文中以「饒」和「任」的歷史發展為例說明。 本文第一部分側重這兩線發展的演變過程、條件和機制,並主張第一線是由代喻機制促成,第二線則是由隱喻機制促成。文中還透過比較指出早期使役條件句帶有「背離事實」的特性,而早期使役讓步條件句則帶有「凸顯對比」的特性。 本文第二部分則進行跨語言比較。首先舉出希臘語as的平行發展,顯示上述兩線發展並非漢語所獨有,而是具有普遍性,且Nikiforidou (1996)所提as虛化的演變條件和演變機制也印證本文的分析。最後指出,使役動詞這兩線發展呈現從「意合連結」(parataxis)到「形合連結」(hypotaxis)的轉變,呼應Hopper and Traugott(2003 [1993])所主張的子句連結漸變過程。
Abstract
This paper discusses the grammatical transformation of Chinese Shi-yi verbs into both conditional conjunctions and concessive conditional conjunctions, which are respectively exemplified by the historical developments of the requesting verbs shi (使) and ling (令) and the letting verbs rao (饒) and ren (任). The first part of this paper focuses on the processes, conditions and mechanisms for the two paths of grammatical transformation. It argues that the mechanism for the first grammatical transformation is metonymy, whereas the second is metaphor. By comparison with other conditionals and concessive conditionals, this paper also demonstrates that the conditionals derived from Shi-yi constructions have the characteristic of being “counterfactual,” whereas the concessive conditionals derived from Shi-yi constructions have the characteristic of being “contrastive.” The second part of this paper focuses on cross-linguistic comparison. The parallel development of the Greek as is introduced to show that the grammaticalization discussed in this paper is not unique to Chinese. The conditions and mechanisms of the grammaticalization of as proposed by Nikiforidou (1996) can also be used to support the analysis in this paper. Finally, this paper points out that the two paths of grammaticalization are from parataxis to hypotaxis, similar to the cline of clause-combining constructions proposed by Hopper and Traugott (2003 [1993]).
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 65期
- 出版
- 2006年11月
- 頁碼
- 001–038
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008125
同期目錄
- 從使役到條件張麗麗(Chang, Li-li)・頁 001–038
- 弋陽腔及其流派考述曾永義(Tseng, Yong-yih)・頁 039–072
- 清代廢園書寫的園林反省與歷史意義侯迺慧(Hou, Nai-huei)・頁 073–112
- 「易屍還魂」的變調──論魯迅小說人物的體格、精神與民族身分顏健富(Guan, Kean-fung)・頁 113–149
- 〈金鎖記〉與《怨女》比較研究郭玉雯(Kuo, Yuh-wen)・頁 151–182
- 光復初期(1945-50)的民族情感與省籍衝突──從臺灣大學的接收改制做觀察李東華(Lee, Tong-hwa)・頁 183–221
- 搬演「詩的正義」──音樂劇《大遊行》中的私怨公演王寶祥(Wang, Pao-hsiang)・頁 223–250
- 尤金.奧尼爾在二十世紀八十年代的中國舞臺上朱雪峰(Zhu, Xue-feng);劉海平(Liu, Hai-ping)・頁 251–274