同志叛國?──同性戀vs.國家之對立性析論
Homosexuality and the Nation: Theorizing the Op-positionality
國立臺灣大學外國語文學系(Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures, National Taiwan University)
摘要
這篇論文一開始先提出冷戰時期美國政界視同性戀者為共產黨的現象,隨即指出類似的指控其實也發生在一九三○年代歐洲共產主義 / 社會主義與納粹法西斯的鬥爭之中(前者當時亦攻擊後者為同性戀),因此在同性戀與這兩種意識形態之間應該並不存在任何本質上的關聯,而毋寧是同一個「將敵人視為性相它者」的政略運用。本文試圖解釋這種政略運用,以理論化同志與國家之間的對立性。然而,兩者的關係最近又似乎有一些正面的例子(譬如魁北克與加拿大),因此本文也加以分析,以解決與上述說法的衝突。同時在整個論述過程中,均穿插虛構文本,以為理論分析之印證說明,這些文本包括:《蜘蛛女之吻》、《草莓與巧克力》、《和散拿》、《摩爾的最後嘆息》,以及《咬狗族》。
Abstract
This essay starts with the Cold War figuration of homosexuals as Communists, and parallels it with the 1930s Communist/socialist accusation of the Nazis/fascists as being homosexual, in order to refute any essentialist connections between homosexuality and either political stance. Instead, an overarching explanation is put forth to encompass both and view them as in effect consisting in the same politics of Othering the enemy in terms of sexuality, which only gets exasperated with the coming of the modern nation. This leads to a theorization of the overdetermined op-positionality between the nation and homosexuality, which is believed to be the real key issue here. However, there are cases (such as Quebec and Canada) in which the relation between the two seems to be not only less tense but rather affirmative—so they are also examined to decide whether they pose a contradiction to the above thesis. Throughout the whole essay, a series of fictional texts are also discussed for illustrations, including Kiss of the Spider Woman, Strawberry and Chocolate, Hosanna, The Moor’s Last Sigh, and Dogeaters.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 64期
- 出版
- 2006年05月
- 頁碼
- 191–223
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008139
同期目錄
- 從甲骨文看漢字構形方式之演化徐富昌(Hsu, Fu-chang)・頁 001–040
- 《史》、《漢》論贊比較十三則李偉泰(Lee, Wei-tai)・頁 041–072
- 論「天人」關係在《竇娥冤》雜劇之演變及其涵義李惠綿(Li, Huei-mian)・頁 073–102
- 閩南方言本字考證(參)徐芳敏(Hsu, Fang-min)・頁 103–129
- 王韜與日本維新人物之思想比較徐興慶(Shyu, Shing-ching)・頁 131–171
- 二(特異)點與一(抽象)線──德勒茲思想的一般拓樸學楊凱麟(Yang, Kai-lin)・頁 173–189
- 同志叛國?──同性戀vs.國家之對立性析論朱偉誠(Chu, Wei-cheng R.)・頁 191–223
- 盯梢東區──伊安辛克萊的《白教堂、紅血跡》、《騰出疆域》陳音頤(Chen, Eva Yin-i)・頁 225–253