故事該怎麼說?-重返三個犯罪現場
How Shall I Relate? Back to the Three Crime Scenes
國立臺灣大學戲劇系(Department of Drama and Theatre, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本文先簡略討論米勒所著之〈直里斯多德的伊底帕斯情結〉,然後追隨米勒的解構式閱讀,比較皮藍德羅之《六個尋找作者之劇中人》與周慧玲之《記憶相簿》,於過程中借重後結構主義的敘述學以彰顯兩個面向:戲劇演變史中敘述策略之遞嬗及晚近戲劇研究方法之變革。誠如米勒所言,「所有以理體中心主義 為基點的文本,皆包含了破壞其中心思想的逆反論證,包含著編織於其內的解構因子」‧《伊底帕斯》表面上為理性代言,但全劇卻奠基於非理性的前提。同樣地,標榜眾聲喧嘩的《六個尋找作者之劇中人》實則極為單音,敘述過程霸氣十足。相對地,《記憶相簿》直接觸碰敘述的政治性質,於述說故事的過程裡頻頻反射性地問道:故事該怎麼說?
Abstract
The paper begins by briefly discussing J. Hillis Miller's critical essay, "Aristotle's Oedipus Complex," and then, loosely applying Miller's methodology, moves on to compare two plays: Luigi Pirandello's Six Characters in Search of an Author and Catherine Chou's Family Album: A Play about Falling. It is hoped that through the comparison the ever changing strategies of narration in drama will be foregrounded. As is well put by Miller, "all logocentric texts contain their own undermining counterargument, their own deconstruction woven into them." On the surface, Oedipus the King seems to emphasize the force of reason in finding the truth about human affairs, but the very premise of the play is in fact based on the irrationality of the gods. Similarly, Six Characters in Search of an Author ostensibly preaches for the multiplicity of reality and human nature, and yet the preaching itself is conducted in a rather monologic manner. By contrast, Family Album: A Play about Falling, by using postmodern techniques of metatheatre, touches upon the politics of narration and, throughout the process of storytelling, constantly confronts the audience with the eternal question about reconstructing past events: how shall I relate?
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 62期
- 出版
- 2005年05月
- 頁碼
- 421–440
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008165
同期目錄
- 戲劇史學專題前言彭鏡禧・頁 001–002
- 製造歷史:非裔美國劇場史的反思Harry J. Elam, Jr.・頁 003–021
- 搜章擿句、翻箱倒篋:以檔案編劇場史Heather S. Nathans・頁 023–045
- 如何重建劇場:以十七世紀法國劇院為例Christa Williford・頁 047–070
- 中世紀劇場的領域Ronald Vince・頁 071–087
- 論道與物關係問題──中國哲學史上的一條主線陳鼓應(Guu-Ying Chen)・頁 089–117
- 從使役到致使張麗麗(Li-Li Chang)・頁 119–151
- 周敦頤的《太極圖說》、《易》象數及西方有關學說張祥龍(Xiang-Long Zhang)・頁 153–182
- 戴震《孟子字義疏證》對人性及人群問題的反省──以《孟子》相關思想為參照簡良如(Liang-Ju Chien)・頁 183–227
- 《紅樓夢》中的「燈」:襲人「告密說」析論歐麗娟(Li-Chuan Ou)・頁 229–275
- 過新生活、做新女性:訓政時期國民政府對時代女性形象的塑造許慧琦(Hui-Chi Hsu)・頁 277–320
- 方豪教授與香港學界的交往及其影響(1950~80)李東華(Tong-Hwa Lee)・頁 321–345
- 語言、戲謔與聯姻:貴州苗人平日游方說話的分析簡美玲(Mei-Ling Chien)・頁 347–380
- 訓詁學新體系之建構:從當前訓詁學研究之回顧與反思談起劉文清(Wen-Ching Liu)・頁 381–419
- 故事該怎麼說?-重返三個犯罪現場紀蔚然(Wei-Jan Chi)・頁 421–440
- 一九七0年代紐約市婦女會爭取女性就業權益策略之研究黃文齡(Wen-Ling Huang)・頁 441–484
- 勃拉恩特:一位早期的美國環境作家盧莉茹(Li-Ru Lu)・頁 485–500