《紅樓夢》中的「石榴花」──賈元春新論
“Pomegranate Flower” in the Dream of the Red Chamber: A New Interpretation of Jia Yuan-chun
國立臺灣大學中國文學系(Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University)
摘要
從文本之掘得知,在《紅樓夢》人花一體之「花文本」中,元春之代表花是為石榴花,而透過情節之互證關涉,更擴延出「石榴花-端午節-女兒節-嫁女思親歸寧-大觀園-元春」之意義脈絡。就其象徵而言,乃借重臺石榴花鮮明紅艷之特點,諭示元春入宮封妃、耀眼非凡之至尊地立;其次則是透過石榴花「開花不及春」之特點,寓涵元春封妃不得其時而使賈府的經濟窘況雪上加霜,造成加速敗落之結果;第三便是由物極全必反的邏輯,強化其從盛夏鼎盛到秋節敗滅的高度反差。至於元春所具備的母神地位,不但主導了大觀園之擘建與女兒國之奠立,更在「命名」上展出至高之權力施為,將整個大觀園都納入到一個由元春所建立的「象徵秩序」與「話語形構」之中;同時也表現於釵黛取捨之決策上,實踐其決定女兒命運的母功能。特別的是,在「二十年來辨是非」的宮廷生活訓練之下,「才德兼備」之元春所具備的乃是客觀品鑒之才與多元涵容之德,透過對齡官的比照分析,可知元春之性格乃是情理兼備、公私分明,同時蘊含了分殊化原則的「自然的理想主義」,又及普遍化原則的「理性的現實主義」,是《紅樓夢》中二元襯補思維的一種具體顯現。
Abstract
This paper identifies the flower symbol of Yuan-chun to be the pomegranate flower. Starting from this, I explore and analyze the meaning nexus of many elements related to the figure of Yuan-chun. First, the bright redness of the pomegranate flower is a simile of the majestic status of Princess Yuan. Second, the pomegranate flower “always blooms after spring”, which hints that the untimely princess-appointment of Yuan-chun further worsens the economic status of the Jia family and thus hastens its decline. Third, the pomegranate flower fully blooms in mid-summer and then declines in the fall, forming a sharp contrast that intensifies a theme of Yuan-chun: After peak comes trough. This paper also discusses the mother-goddess status of Yuan-chun. It is first of all expressed in Yuan-chun’s initiation of the establishment of Prospect Garden and her right to nominate locations wherein, thus giving a symbolic structure (a nomos-morpholism) to Prospect Garden. It also expresses itself in her cholice between Bau-chai and Dai-yu. Last but not least, under the discipline of palace life (“distinguishing right from wrong, proper from improper for twenty years”), Yuan-chun has cultivated both the talent of objective appreciation and the virtue of sympathetic leniency. She embodies both the individuation principle of natural idealism and the universal principle of rational realism. This exemplifies the complementary dualism of the Dream of the Red Chamber.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 60期
- 出版
- 2004年05月
- 頁碼
- 113–156
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008183
同期目錄
- 禮制國家的組構── 以《二戴記》的論述形式剖析漢代儒化世界的形成陳志信(Chih-Hsin Chen)・頁 001–044
- 「理」範疇理論模式的道家詮釋陳鼓應(Guu-Ying Chen)・頁 045–074
- 長安唐詩與樂遊原現地研究簡錦松(Chin-Sung Chien)・頁 075–111
- 《紅樓夢》中的「石榴花」──賈元春新論歐麗娟(Li-Chuan Ou)・頁 113–156
- 論一九三三年之「察馮事件」──以「軍閥政治」觀點之考察李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 157–197
- 論「故」的虛化及其在閩方言中的表現楊秀芳(Hsiu-Fang Yang)・頁 199–242
- 柏拉圖線喻中的認知對象問題何畫瑰(Hua-kuei Ho)・頁 243–263
- 謝勒知識社會學的背景──文化社會學關永中(Wing-Chung Kwan)・頁 265–295
- 藝術生態壁龕中的創作者、作品與觀者:淺談貢布里希與藝術社會學之間的關係陳美杏(Mei-Hsin Chen)・頁 297–338
- 1626 年西班牙入侵台灣的「正當化」鮑曉鷗(José Eugenio Borao)・頁 339–372