柏拉圖線喻中的認知對象問題
The Problem of Objects of Cognition in Plato's Analogy of the Line
國立臺灣大學哲學系(Department of Philosophy, National Taiwan University)
摘要
如果我們相信,從認知對象在存有學上的差異,可以決定所獲得的認知狀態,並由這樣的進路理解柏拉圖《理想國》中的線喻,便必須先確立出四 種不同的存在作為認知對象,分配給線喻中的四個線段,以對這四種對象的存有學解釋的基礎,去理解這個譬喻所要說明的四種認知狀態。然而,這樣的進路將會遇到困難。文中將以陳康、Julia Annas為例,說明這種進路中,很難確定代表各線段的四種隊同認知對象各是什麼,而且往往還須回到認知方式的不同來推測對象;此外,一進路將遭遇下列兩項後果:一是和相同對象可能產生不同認知狀態的事實衝突;另一則是和線喻中間兩線段等長的事實衝突。面對這些困難,文末建議必須透過認和方式去推測、分辨認知對象,以此修正對線喻的解釋。
Abstract
This article takes the analogy of the Line in Plato’s Republic as an example, and deals with the relation between objects and cognitive status. In some important interpretations, scholars (e.g. Ludwig C. H. Chen and Julia Annas) attempt to assign four different objects four sections of the basis of epistemology in the analogy of the Line. However, such an approach seems to be improper. For it is difficult to find a consistent assignment of objects for all sections of the Line, especially if we ignore how we reach each cognitive status (represented by each section of the Line). At the same time, it is possible to have the same objects for different cognitive status, and the middle two sections of the Line hold the same length. Thus, a neat ontological assignment of objects might be inconsistent with these two facts. However, if we distinguish the objects by the different methods by which we inquire them, all these troubles will be solved. Therefore, this article suggests that, instead of the ontological difference of objects, it is the different ways of inquiring objects that decide our cognitive status.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 60期
- 出版
- 2004年05月
- 頁碼
- 243–263
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008186
同期目錄
- 禮制國家的組構── 以《二戴記》的論述形式剖析漢代儒化世界的形成陳志信(Chih-Hsin Chen)・頁 001–044
- 「理」範疇理論模式的道家詮釋陳鼓應(Guu-Ying Chen)・頁 045–074
- 長安唐詩與樂遊原現地研究簡錦松(Chin-Sung Chien)・頁 075–111
- 《紅樓夢》中的「石榴花」──賈元春新論歐麗娟(Li-Chuan Ou)・頁 113–156
- 論一九三三年之「察馮事件」──以「軍閥政治」觀點之考察李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 157–197
- 論「故」的虛化及其在閩方言中的表現楊秀芳(Hsiu-Fang Yang)・頁 199–242
- 柏拉圖線喻中的認知對象問題何畫瑰(Hua-kuei Ho)・頁 243–263
- 謝勒知識社會學的背景──文化社會學關永中(Wing-Chung Kwan)・頁 265–295
- 藝術生態壁龕中的創作者、作品與觀者:淺談貢布里希與藝術社會學之間的關係陳美杏(Mei-Hsin Chen)・頁 297–338
- 1626 年西班牙入侵台灣的「正當化」鮑曉鷗(José Eugenio Borao)・頁 339–372