1626 年西班牙入侵台灣的「正當化」
The “Justification” of the Spanish Intrusion in Taiwan in 1626
國立臺灣大學外國語文學系(Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures, National Taiwan University)
摘要
在所謂「恢復失地」(Reconquista)時期(711-1492),伊比利半島上的基督教王國和回教王國爭戰有八枓年之久,因此產生了一個習於戰鬥的社會,隨後轉而征服美洲。當傳教士報導了西班牙征服者和殖民者對於印第安人的第一批暴行,西班牙王室開始慮應否繼續支持殖民的活動,特別是有否法律根據足以將其正當化。當時的學者很快體認到,征服美洲截然不同於先前的「恢復失地」。回教徒被認為是竑基督教的,更是入侵者。相反的,美洲印第安人只能算為是異教徒,卻是他們自己王國的真正統治者。於是在十六世紀的西班牙大學,如Salamanca,興起了一場相關問題的復雜辯論。 這辯論最主要的成果是,精心地邁構出一種不同於羅馬法的近代國際關係學說。學者之中,以多明我會士Fraciso de Vitoria所提出理論最具影響力。他強調說,征服美洲印第安人且使他們改變信仰,只有當土著在個由的情況下,接受西班牙的統治,並皈依基督教,才算是合法。 本文藉由臺灣的個案研究,試圖分析當菲律賓的西班牙人計畫征服新領土時,當時有關殖民的理論扮演什麼角色。首先我們將審視十六世末征服福爾摩沙島的計畫,然後集中探討1626年實際的佔領行動。有一些研究宣稱碩學之士Vitoria為此歷史過程提供主要的歷史基礎,但我們認為,Vitoria理論和實際軍事考量的結合才是當時殖民「正當化」的概念模式。
Abstract
The Christian kingdoms of the Iberian Peninsula were figihting the Muslim kingdoms in the region for eight centuries during the period known as the Reconquista (711-1492). This created a society accustomed to fighting, whose energies were then directed to the conquest of America. Once the first atrocities of the conquistadores and colonizers against the Indians were reported by some missionaries, the Spanish Crown started to consider if this historical process could be continued or not, and if there were any legal bases that might justify it. Very soon the scholars of that time realized that the reason for the Reconquista (the recovery of their land from the Moors) was different from that of the Conquest of America. Muslims were considered as antichristian and intruders. On the contrary, the Amerindians could only be considered as pagans and the real rulers of their kingdoms. A complex debate arose in Spanish universities such as Salamanca on this question in the 16th century. The main fruit of all this discussion was the elaboration of a modern doctrine for international relations, different from that of Roman Law. The scholar whose theories were most influential was the Dominican Farancisco de Vitoria. For this the conquest and conversion of the Amerindians could only be legitimate if the natives freely accepted the sovereignty of Spain and adhered to the Christian faith. The present paper seeks to analyze, through the case study of Taiwan, to what extent the Spaniards in the Philippines were bound by the theories of that time when they were planning the conquest of a new territory. First we will review the projects of conquest of Isla Hermosa at the end of the 16th century, and later we will focus our study on some of the reasons used to justify the actual occupation, the took place in 1626. some claimed to be based on the theories of Master Vitoria, but, in our opinion, a combination of both Vitoria theories and practical military approaches were behind the whole rationale.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 60期
- 出版
- 2004年05月
- 頁碼
- 339–372
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008189
同期目錄
- 禮制國家的組構── 以《二戴記》的論述形式剖析漢代儒化世界的形成陳志信(Chih-Hsin Chen)・頁 001–044
- 「理」範疇理論模式的道家詮釋陳鼓應(Guu-Ying Chen)・頁 045–074
- 長安唐詩與樂遊原現地研究簡錦松(Chin-Sung Chien)・頁 075–111
- 《紅樓夢》中的「石榴花」──賈元春新論歐麗娟(Li-Chuan Ou)・頁 113–156
- 論一九三三年之「察馮事件」──以「軍閥政治」觀點之考察李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 157–197
- 論「故」的虛化及其在閩方言中的表現楊秀芳(Hsiu-Fang Yang)・頁 199–242
- 柏拉圖線喻中的認知對象問題何畫瑰(Hua-kuei Ho)・頁 243–263
- 謝勒知識社會學的背景──文化社會學關永中(Wing-Chung Kwan)・頁 265–295
- 藝術生態壁龕中的創作者、作品與觀者:淺談貢布里希與藝術社會學之間的關係陳美杏(Mei-Hsin Chen)・頁 297–338
- 1626 年西班牙入侵台灣的「正當化」鮑曉鷗(José Eugenio Borao)・頁 339–372