南庄地區開發與賽夏族群邊界問題的再檢視
Re-examining the Development of the Nanzhuang Area and the Ethnic Boundary of the Saisiat in Taiwan
國立臺灣大學人類學系(Department of Anthropology, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本文主要從歷史和文化動態對話的觀點,探討新竹苗栗山區賽夏族的族群邊界形塑與區域開發互動的關聯。透過歷史文獻和檔案、民族誌記錄、田野調查資料、和族人自我詮釋資料等綜合運用,一方面試圖檢視地區開發過程中,不同時代階段國家政策、地方資源、和人群互動的變化;另一方面也重新思考跨時代流動變化中反覆再現的「賽夏」特質,以及族群邊界形塑的可能機制。賽夏的例子,顯現出其族群邊界形塑過程,受到新竹苗栗交界山區的人群接觸、交易、移墾、殖民、軍事和行政區劃等各種政治經濟活動的影響,而日漸具體化和強化。但是,隨著社會生活環境的長時間發展變化,反而更凸顯出文化內在動趨力所引導的一些特定運作方向或原則;例如,「開山撫番」以來山區聚落的遷移模式與賽夏聚落性質、賽夏「家名」至「姓氏」的轉換等。總之,從動態對話的角度來思考族群邊界的流動,應該能夠更細緻的掌握歷史過程中人群互動關係的變化,以及理解當代與過去、內部價值觀念與外在刺激持續在實際生活中的對話與連結。
Abstract
This paper aims at discussing the connection between the establishment of ethnic boundary of the Saisiat people and the development of the adjoining Nanzhuang area. By using historical materials, archives, ethnographies, field notes, and the Saisiat self-produced materials, on the one hand, we would like to examine the influences brought by the changes of state policies, exploitation of local resources and cross-cultural encounters in different times. On the other hand, we propose to investigate the constantly manifested "Siasiat-ness" features, as well as the possible institutions for shaping up the ethnic boundary under historical changes. In the case of Saisiat, it is shown that its ethnic boundary was influenced by the interactions with different groups of people who entered in the mountainous area of Xinzhu and Miaoli counties, and also reinforced by the outside economical and political impacts, such as trade market, land reclamation, military operation and administrative classification. Yet, in distinction to the external socio-economic changes, certain cultural codes and conceptual schema in the aboriginal society ought to be highlighted as extending agencies for integration. For instance, the special pattern of movement of the related aboriginal settlements since the "opening up the mountains and pacifying the aborigines" (kaishan fufan) scheme in the 1880s; and the systematic transformation from the aboriginal clan names to specific Han-Chinese surnames with similar meanings. In conclusion, to examine more subtle social changes in the historical processes, and to measure the ethnic boundary from a more fluid and dynamic point of view, we might have gained deeper understanding of the complicated dynamic interactions between different groups of people, and of the continuous discourse between the internal cultural values and external stimulants, as well as the past and the present.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 59期
- 出版
- 2003年11月
- 頁碼
- 177–214
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008197
同期目錄
- 專題導論: 人類學研究的歷史化黃應貴(Ying-Kuei Huang)・頁 001–010
- 人類學與歷史學的對話?──一點反省與建議林開世(Kai-Shyh Lin)・頁 011–029
- 歷史與記憶之間:從大關山事件談起楊淑媛(Shu-Yuan Yang)・頁 031–063
- 歷史書寫、主體性與權力:對「排灣人寫排灣族歷史」的觀察與反思譚昌國(Chang-Kwo Tan)・頁 065–095
- 環境、空間與區域:地理學觀點下十七世紀中葉「大肚王」統治的消長康培德(Peter Kang)・頁 097–115
- 贌社、地域與平埔社群的成立詹素娟(Su-Chuan Chan)・頁 117–141
- 民族誌與歷史研究的對話:以「卑南族」形成與發展的探討為例陳文德(Wen-Te Chen)・頁 143–175
- 南庄地區開發與賽夏族群邊界問題的再檢視胡家瑜(Chia-Yu Hu);林欣宜(Hsin-Yi Lin)・頁 177–214
- 先秦至唐代「戲劇」與「戲曲小戲」劇目考述曾永義(Yong-Yih Tseng)・頁 215–266
- 韓愈「獲麟解」析論:由「形」與「德」看韓愈之所以為韓愈方介(Chieh Fang)・頁 267–295
- 女性節日文化初探:以近代方志中的「元宵走橋」等習俗為例洪淑苓(Shu-Ling Horng)・頁 297–336
- 德勒茲「思想─影像」或「思想=影像」之條件及問題性楊凱麟(KaiLin Yang)・頁 337–367
- 文學作品當旅遊導讀:霍桑「大理石牧神」影像插圖本的由來與意涵鄭永孝(Yung-Hsiao Cheng)・頁 369–400
- 莎翁歷史劇「亨利八世」中之凱瑟琳皇后與矛盾鄭惠芳(Wai-Fong Cheang)・頁 401–422
- 插畫家的肖像:「真品」的美學與倫理李欣穎(Hsin-Ying Li)・頁 423–445