插畫家的肖像:「真品」的美學與倫理
The Portrait of the Illustrator: Reconciling the Esthetic and the Ethical in “The Real Thing”
國立臺灣大學外國語文學系(Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures, National Taiwan University)
摘要
批評家一向認為亨利.詹姆士的〈真品〉闡揚創作者如何超越真實而創造藝術。少部分的批評家則注意到故事的道德主題,即悲憫的胸懷才能造就偉大的藝術。然而這兩種創作法則在故事中卻互相抵觸。 本文認為〈真品〉的藝術家敘述者其實是詹姆士的負面教材。小說家藉由評比攝影、插畫與肖像三種視覺藝術,譏刺敘述者無法超脫浪漫的理想主義進入創意的寫主義。攝影被視為缺乏創意與深度,而插畫卻力求捕捉特定類型之共通特質,唯有肖像兼顧了形似與神似。不同的美學目的更影響了藝術家與模特兒之間的倫理。敘述者做為插畫家,只將職業模特兒當作道具;唯因他夢想成為肖像畫家,才能同情落魄求職的紳士淑女。可惜他欠缺觀察力與包容心,終究未能將人生的真實轉化為藝術的真實。
Abstract
Henry James “The Real Thing” has traditionally been read as a lesson in art: namely, that art is a transformation rather than a copy of reality. A few critics have also commented on the moral theme of the story: that human compassion makes a better artist. The two readings, however, conflict with each other, because the artist in the story is forced to turn his back on his non-professional models to maintain his artistic integrity, while conceding that his art suffers"a permanent harm." This paper argues that the artist-narrator of the story actually fails the test to pass from romantic idealism to creative realism, which would have reconciled the esthetic with the ethical. The three art forms in the story-photography, illustration and portraiture-reflect James' appraisal of the creative process. Photography, as literary realism, lacks both creativity and depth. Illustration, meanwhile, though the narrator stresses imagination, seeks generalizations at the expense of individuality. Only portraiture achieves both verisimilitude and character. The differences in esthetic purposes affect the ethical relation between the artist and his subject. The illustratornarrator rarely treats his professional model as more than props on a stage. His ambition to become a portraitist, on the other hand, leads him to sympathize with the Monarchs. Yet his lack of the penetrating eye and of an impartial understanding suggests that he finally falls short of his aspirations. James, tale thus teaches, by a negative example, not so much now to transcend life to achieve the real thing in art, but how to transform the real thing in life into the real thing in art.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 59期
- 出版
- 2003年11月
- 頁碼
- 423–445
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008204
同期目錄
- 專題導論: 人類學研究的歷史化黃應貴(Ying-Kuei Huang)・頁 001–010
- 人類學與歷史學的對話?──一點反省與建議林開世(Kai-Shyh Lin)・頁 011–029
- 歷史與記憶之間:從大關山事件談起楊淑媛(Shu-Yuan Yang)・頁 031–063
- 歷史書寫、主體性與權力:對「排灣人寫排灣族歷史」的觀察與反思譚昌國(Chang-Kwo Tan)・頁 065–095
- 環境、空間與區域:地理學觀點下十七世紀中葉「大肚王」統治的消長康培德(Peter Kang)・頁 097–115
- 贌社、地域與平埔社群的成立詹素娟(Su-Chuan Chan)・頁 117–141
- 民族誌與歷史研究的對話:以「卑南族」形成與發展的探討為例陳文德(Wen-Te Chen)・頁 143–175
- 南庄地區開發與賽夏族群邊界問題的再檢視胡家瑜(Chia-Yu Hu);林欣宜(Hsin-Yi Lin)・頁 177–214
- 先秦至唐代「戲劇」與「戲曲小戲」劇目考述曾永義(Yong-Yih Tseng)・頁 215–266
- 韓愈「獲麟解」析論:由「形」與「德」看韓愈之所以為韓愈方介(Chieh Fang)・頁 267–295
- 女性節日文化初探:以近代方志中的「元宵走橋」等習俗為例洪淑苓(Shu-Ling Horng)・頁 297–336
- 德勒茲「思想─影像」或「思想=影像」之條件及問題性楊凱麟(KaiLin Yang)・頁 337–367
- 文學作品當旅遊導讀:霍桑「大理石牧神」影像插圖本的由來與意涵鄭永孝(Yung-Hsiao Cheng)・頁 369–400
- 莎翁歷史劇「亨利八世」中之凱瑟琳皇后與矛盾鄭惠芳(Wai-Fong Cheang)・頁 401–422
- 插畫家的肖像:「真品」的美學與倫理李欣穎(Hsin-Ying Li)・頁 423–445