日本德川時代神儒兼攝學者對「神道」「儒道」的解釋特色
The Characteristics of Confucian-Shintoist Thinkers' Interpretation of Confucianism and Shintoism in Tokugawa Japan
臺北醫學大學通識教育中心(Center for General Education, Taipei Medical University)
摘要
本文旨在分析日本德川時代神儒兼攝思想家對儒家經典的解釋特色,所謂「神儒兼攝」是指該學者一方面是儒者,一方面又有鮮明的日本本土的神道信仰,舉凡朱子學者林羅山 (1583-1657) 、山崎闇齋 (1618-1682), 陽明學者熊澤蕃山 (1619.1691), 兵學者山鹿素行 (1622-1685) 、松宮觀山 (1686-1780),以及幕末的尊皇攘夷的水戶學者與勤皇學者等都具有「神儒兼攝」的特色。因此,本文第二節首先論述日本「傳統」的發展與演變,並分析神儒兼攝思想家在捍衛自己文化傳統之同時,也必須斬斷與中國文化淵源之關係。第三節則分析這些神儒兼攝者,展現他們的文化主體性以尋求彼此之「道」的共通性,分析「神儒習合」與「神儒一其揍」兩種調和方式, 「神儒合一」者表面上調融神、儒之道,但精神上大皆仍由儒學來理解神道;「神儒一其揆」者,則以神道為主,儒學為輔,儒學僅能當作次要地位。第四節即分析有關於堯舜禪讓與湯武放伐的政治思想所帶給神儒兼攝學者們無可避免之緊張性。最後在結論中兼論日本學者解決神儒之道衝突之態度,常以「神」對抗「人」的思維,來達到宣示中日之道仍有根本不同之目的,不免帶來主體性膨脹的問題。
Abstract
This essay intends first to analyze the features of Confucian-Shint o ist thinkers' interpretation of the Confucian Classics in the late Tokugawa Japan. The term "Confucian- Shint o ist believers"(神儒兼攝者) refer to those who were Confucianist, but also had a strong belief in Japanese Shint o ism .The Way of Gods .. They included Chu-Tzu scholars, Hayashi Razan (林羅山 1583-1657), Yamazaki Ansai (山崎闇齋 1618-1882), Yangming school's Kumazawa Banzan (熊澤蕃山1619-1691), Military School's Yamaga Soko (山鹿素行 1622-1685) , and the Mikado scholars (尊皇學者). The second section essay explores the development and evolution of the Japanese traditionalism first, and then analyses the way in which these Confucian- Shint o ist believers broke the connection of Japanese culture to Chinese culture when defending their own cultural tradition. The third section illustrates how these thinkers expanded their cultural subjectivity to find something in common in the two cultures, explaining their two solutions for harmonization. "Confucian-Shint o ist believers", on the surface, harmonized conflicting elements, but in fact interpreted Shint o ism in terms of Confucianism, while "Shint o ist-Confucian theorists" put Shint o ism ahead of Confucianism. The fourth section expounds the inevitable tensions that Chinese political ideas, "Yao-Shun Shan Rang Rulership" (舜禪讓政治) and "Tang-Wu Revolution", posed to these Confucian-Shint o ist believers. The concluding part explains the Japanese thinkers' attitude toward how to solve the conflicting elements between Confucianism and Shint o ism. The afore-mentioned thinkers habitually countered "human" thought with "divine" thought. Showing that Chinese Confucianism and Japanese Shint o ism had different ultimate ends, they reinterpreted the ancient texts in terms of "subjective inflation"
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 58期
- 出版
- 2003年05月
- 頁碼
- 141–179
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008209
同期目錄
- 王弼道家易學詮釋陳鼓應(Chen, Guu-ying)・頁 001–023
- 杜甫詩中的親子關係與教育觀──兼論詩史之開拓與創新歐麗娟(Li-Chuan Ou)・頁 025–070
- 因「亂」而致的心理創傷:漢族士人對蒙古入侵回應之研究田浩(Hoyt Cleveland Tillman)・頁 071–093
- 家族與科舉:宋元明休寧程氏的發展,1100-1644朱開宇(Ki-You Chu)・頁 095–140
- 日本德川時代神儒兼攝學者對「神道」「儒道」的解釋特色張崑將(Kun-Chiang Chang)・頁 141–179
- 海德格與高達美哲學的提問(Fragen)與思考(Denken)陳榮華(Wing-Wah Chan)・頁 181–209
- 姜生「翻譯」牧歌的操作典範及牧歌文類的「翻譯現象」張惠鍞(Huei-Keng Chang)・頁 211–229
- 重新評估察米雅欽的「我們」張惠娟(Hui-Chuan Chang)・頁 231–250
- 我買故我在:芭芭拉‧克魯格與消費文化曾少千(Shao-Chien Tseng)・頁 251–295
- 「自由派的帝國主義」:英國對埃政策,1893-94王世宗(Shih-Tsung Wang)・頁 297–333