重新評估察米雅欽的「我們」
Zamyatin's We: A Reassessment
國立臺灣大學外國語文學系(Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures, National Taiwan University)
摘要
俄國作家察米雅欽的《我們》在反烏托邦文學中具有舉足輕重的地位,是此一文類的開山祖之一。然而,傳統上反烏托邦文學的研究者所關注的,多為其社會批判的層面,亦即反烏托邦是針對當前社會走向所發出的「預警」。此等「內容掛帥」的閱讀方式無法發掘《我們》在內涵和文體上所展露的活潑多變的風貌,以是本論文希冀提供另一視角,以補傳統閱讀的不足。由內涵與文體兩方面觀之,皆可見《我們》作為一反烏托邦小說的獨特性。《我們》是一個深具「開放性」的反烏托邦,在內涵上刻意呈現意識形態的不受制約,在文體上則採取深具自我意識的後設技巧, 徹底顛覆反烏托邦小說單元 / 封閉的敘事空間。相較於其他反烏托邦小說,《我們》具有開放的辯證特質,在反烏托邦的陰鬱中重燃烏托邦的樂觀希望。
Abstract
This paper means to draw attention to the uniqueness of Yevgeny Zamyatin's We as a "heretical" product, a work that stands aloof among modern dystopias in many aspects. Ideologically as well as textually, We is a dynamic, open-ended dystopia, foregrounding ideological free play and narrative indeterminacy. Its articulation of multiplicity of perspectives defies any assertion of absolutism or authority and destabilizes whatever illusion of closure the text may have harbored. Its recourse to various metafictional techniques further unravels a textual world where everything is just in the process of becoming and nothing has already been finished. The departure of We from the realist tradition upheld by other dystopias is significant in negotiating a strategy to counter the official, orthodox narrative and eventually to provide a glimpse of hope for the otherwise dark world.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大文史哲學報
- ISSN
- 1015-2687
- 卷期
- 58期
- 出版
- 2003年05月
- 頁碼
- 231–250
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008212
同期目錄
- 王弼道家易學詮釋陳鼓應(Chen, Guu-ying)・頁 001–023
- 杜甫詩中的親子關係與教育觀──兼論詩史之開拓與創新歐麗娟(Li-Chuan Ou)・頁 025–070
- 因「亂」而致的心理創傷:漢族士人對蒙古入侵回應之研究田浩(Hoyt Cleveland Tillman)・頁 071–093
- 家族與科舉:宋元明休寧程氏的發展,1100-1644朱開宇(Ki-You Chu)・頁 095–140
- 日本德川時代神儒兼攝學者對「神道」「儒道」的解釋特色張崑將(Kun-Chiang Chang)・頁 141–179
- 海德格與高達美哲學的提問(Fragen)與思考(Denken)陳榮華(Wing-Wah Chan)・頁 181–209
- 姜生「翻譯」牧歌的操作典範及牧歌文類的「翻譯現象」張惠鍞(Huei-Keng Chang)・頁 211–229
- 重新評估察米雅欽的「我們」張惠娟(Hui-Chuan Chang)・頁 231–250
- 我買故我在:芭芭拉‧克魯格與消費文化曾少千(Shao-Chien Tseng)・頁 251–295
- 「自由派的帝國主義」:英國對埃政策,1893-94王世宗(Shih-Tsung Wang)・頁 297–333