「左傳」「人生始化曰魄」辨
On the Interpretation of "ran sheng shi hua yue po" in Zuozhuan
香港浸會大學中文系(Department of Chinese Language and Literature, Hong Kong Baptist University)
- 卷期
- 57期
- 出版
- 2002年11月
- 頁碼
- 211–221
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008221
摘要
《左傳》「人生始化曰魄」一句歷來有兩種疏解,一以「化」為「變化成形」,另一則以為「死亡漸滅」;兩義之所以完全相反,其實決定於對後面「魄」字的理解。前者認為「魄」是「附形之靈」,後者則以為「魄」是「陰神」。本文先考查文獻中「化」、「魄」兩字的用例用義,然後再收結於《左傳》的內部證據,論證「魄」當指人的識如主體,並非死後方有,而全句則當解作「人出生成形時具有識知主體」。
Abstract
This article deals with the interpretation of the sentence "ran sheng shi hua yue po" in Zuozhuan, in particular, the meaning of the words "hua (化)" and "po (魄)". There have been two interpretations squarely opposite to each other. One views "hua" as "to come into being" and the other "to cease to exist". Such divergence is in fact a result of the interpretation of "po", whether it should mean "the sense-mind attached to a living body" or "the spirit of a deceased person" . This article starts by surveying external evidence-the usage and meaning of relevant words in contemporary Chinese literature; and then, relying on internal evidence of Zuozhuan, concludes that "po" means "sense-mind attached to a living body". As a result, the entire sentence should be interpreted as "when a person comes into being there is the sense-mind" .