書評:蘇珊.列芬《重返哲學與詩之間的古老爭執──柏拉圖與希臘的文學傳統》
Critical Book Review: Susan B. Levin, «The Ancient Quarrel between Philosophy and Poetry Revisited--Plato and the Greek Literary Tradition»
國立臺灣大學哲學系(Department of Philosophy, National Taiwan University)
- 卷期
- 57期
- 出版
- 2002年11月
- 頁碼
- 223–232
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008222
摘要
本文試圖為蘇珊‧列芬新作進行書評。蘇珊. 列芬從柏拉圖語言哲學延伸出新的觀點,重新處理哲學典詩之間的爭執。進路新穎,卻有相當高的可行性,達到很好的成果。但本書中,詭辯術或其他哲學觀點僅僅被視為這篇對話的非主要對手,似乎並不恰當。此外,作者最具有獨創性的兩項論點,仍值得商榷:一、關於「正確名稱」指涉對象的說明;二、作者協調《理想國》第二、三卷及第十卷的辦法。就第一點,本文質疑這套正確名稱的說法是否能適用於專名;就第二點,則以柏拉圖詩論中的「模仿」問題加以檢視。期能對本書提供一項批判性討論的可能。
Abstract
This piece reviews Levin's new work. Levin develops her study of Plato's philosophy of language. With such a new study, she revisits the quarrel between philosophy and poetry. This book achieves some worthy results. Yet the significant role of the sophistry seems to escape Levin's notice. Besides, I argue with her for two points: First, she states a good explanation for the referents of correct names, while it needs a further explanation whether this can work in the cases of proper names. Second, she tries to show the consistence of the Republic II, III and X, while I doubt whether this attempt can face Plato's strong position against mimesis in poetry.