The Missing Operational Components of the IHR (2005) from the Experience of Handling the Outbreak of COVID-19: Precaution, Independence, Transparency and Universality
National Taiwan University College of Law
摘要
In December 2019, there was an outbreak of pneumonia caused by Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) in Wuhan City, China. It was unfortunate that the outbreak has taken so many lives. It was partly because that the handling of the outbreak by the World Health Organization (hereinafter “WHO”) was not timely or appropriate. There are so many positive and negative lessons we can learn from the outbreak. At the international level, WHO is supposed to lead the world to fight against the outbreak based on the International Health Regulations (2005) (hereinafter “IHR (2005)”). However, it is apparent that there are many operational problems with the IHR (2005). The role of the IHR (2005) seems not to be critical in guiding States Parties for tackling the outbreak. The operation of the IHR (2005) can definitely be improved to make the system more capable of addressing life-threatening and life-saving issues. First, the compliance with the requirements of the IHR (2005) should be seriously addressed. Second, the independence of the Emergency Committee and that of the WHO Director-General should also be addressed so as to respect the desirable independence in performing their duties. Third, the transparency issue should also be addressed to help the country where the public health emergency of international concern (hereinafter “PHEIC”) occurs to faithfully respect the disclosure requirement and to become more transparent. Fourth, the timeliness and precautionary principle should be dealt with so as to require a timely decision of a PHEIC and to ensure that the precautionary principle plays a supplementary role to help the declaration of a PHEIC in a timely and efficient manner. Fifth, WHO, its Director-General and States Parties of the IHR (2005) should also be expected to allow non-Parties’ meaningful participation in the operation of the IHR (2005).
Abstract
In December 2019, there was an outbreak of pneumonia caused by Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) in Wuhan City, China. It was unfortunate that the outbreak has taken so many lives. It was partly because that the handling of the outbreak by the World Health Organization (hereinafter “WHO”) was not timely or appropriate. There are so many positive and negative lessons we can learn from the outbreak. At the international level, WHO is supposed to lead the world to fight against the outbreak based on the International Health Regulations (2005) (hereinafter “IHR (2005)”). However, it is apparent that there are many operational problems with the IHR (2005). The role of the IHR (2005) seems not to be critical in guiding States Parties for tackling the outbreak. The operation of the IHR (2005) can definitely be improved to make the system more capable of addressing life-threatening and life-saving issues. First, the compliance with the requirements of the IHR (2005) should be seriously addressed. Second, the independence of the Emergency Committee and that of the WHO Director-General should also be addressed so as to respect the desirable independence in performing their duties. Third, the transparency issue should also be addressed to help the country where the public health emergency of international concern (hereinafter “PHEIC”) occurs to faithfully respect the disclosure requirement and to become more transparent. Fourth, the timeliness and precautionary principle should be dealt with so as to require a timely decision of a PHEIC and to ensure that the precautionary principle plays a supplementary role to help the declaration of a PHEIC in a timely and efficient manner. Fifth, WHO, its Director-General and States Parties of the IHR (2005) should also be expected to allow non-Parties’ meaningful participation in the operation of the IHR (2005).
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 15卷1期
- 出版
- 2020年03月
- 頁碼
- 1–26
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000084
同期目錄
- The Missing Operational Components of the IHR (2005) from the Experience of Handling the Outbreak of COVID-19: Precaution, Independence, Transparency and UniversalityChang-fa Lo・頁 1–26
- Global Health in a Turbulence Time: A CommentaryTsung-Ling Lee・頁 27–60
- Regional Mechanism Under Doha Paragraph 6 System—The Largely Untested Alternative Route for Access to Patented MedicinesTolulope Anthony Adekola・頁 61–90
- Tightrope Walk Between Faith and Scepticism: India’s “Contingency Plan” for Free TradeDebashis Chakraborty & Julien Chaisse・頁 91–168
- Imported Seafood Traceability Regulations: A Mishap for the WTO’s Disregard for Non-Product Related Processes and Production Methods?Juan He・頁 169–208
- The Stalemate in China’s GPA Accession Negotiations—Is There a Way Out?Marcia Don Harpaz & Hadas Peled・頁 209–258
- The Applicability of GATT Rules to Gas Transit Against the Backdrop of the “Belt and Road Initiative”: China’s Pipeline Transit TransportZhong Lei・頁 259–284
- Africa-China Investment Partnership for Development: The Downside, the Promises and a Roadmap for the FutureCollins C. Ajibo, Miriam C. Anozie, Timothy O. Umahi & Samuel I. Nwatu・頁 285–318
- The Americanization of the International Economic Order and Its Normative BoundariesAsif H Qureshi・頁 319–350
- E-cigarettes, Public Health, and Scientific Uncertainty: A Book Review on Lukasz Gruszczynski (Ed.), “The Regulation of E-cigarettes: International, European and National Challenges”Silvia Nuzzo・頁 351–357