I Am a Cat中的「不可譯性」:主體性・作品類型・藝術・文本規範・宗教性
On the Untranslatability of I Am a Cat: Subjectivity, Genre, Art, Textual Norms, and Religion
國立臺灣大學日本語文學系專案助理教授(Project Assistant Professor of Department of Japanese Language and Literature, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本研究考察夏目漱石《我是貓》之英譯本,Katsue Shibata; Motonari Kai譯I Am A Cat及Aiko Itō; Graeme Wilson譯I Am a Cat。採用Emily Apter所提出之「不可譯性」為方法,以主體性、作品類型、藝術、文本規範、宗教性為核心,揭示原作與英譯之文化背景,並觀察兩英譯
本之通時性變化。
個別事例考察結果如下。(1)英譯本呈現從直譯到將訴求人類平等的英文學傳統運用到翻譯上的變化。(2)俳句在英譯本中呈現為已被認識的作品類型,然而英譯本對於俳句背景的認識程度不深。(3)不同於具有日本鳥獸畫背景的原作,英譯本(後者)在「繪畫」的解釋上可看出對英國“Picturesque”的認知。(4)關於原作中的「漢文脈」,英譯本譯出了專有名詞的部分,卻無法完全掌握文脈含義。(5)英譯以基督教的詞彙取代原作中的佛教語。
Abstract
This study investigated two translations of Sōseki Natsume’s I Am a Cat: one by Katsue Shibata and Motonari Kai, and the other by Aiko Itō and Graeme Wilson. Based on Emily Apter’s concept of Untranslatability, the study clarified the cultural backgrounds of the original text and the English versions. The results were as follows: (1)The English translation showed a change from the literal translation to bring to the fore the human equality by presenting the tradition of English literature. (2) In the English translated works, the haiku genre related to the original text’s creative background is well established, but the understanding of the haiku is not deepened. (3) Unlike the original text with the background of Japanese-style paintings of birds and beasts, the later English translated work presents the understanding of picturesque views. (4) Regarding the contexts of Chinese classics used in the original text, the proper nouns are translated into English counterparts, but some of the meanings of the contexts are not understood thoroughly by the translators. (5) The English translation replaces vocabulary of Buddhist with Christian vocabulary.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大日本語文研究
- ISSN
- 1609-8978
- 卷期
- 43期
- 出版
- 2022年06月
- 頁碼
- 033–062
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008797
同期目錄
- 大鹿卓研究-以戰前昭和期的現代主義文學為視角-簡中昊(Chien, Chung-Hao)・頁 001–032
- I Am a Cat中的「不可譯性」:主體性・作品類型・藝術・文本規範・宗教性吳勤文(Ching-wen Wu)・頁 033–062
- 從形容詞思考日本昔話詞彙―以基本度・品詞比・語意領域為線索—林立萍(Li-Ping Lin)・頁 063–085
- 從「名詞+だけだ」來觀察「量」與「質」的交錯―兼以中日對照的觀點―陳昭心(Jaushin CHEN)・頁 087–116
- 關於日文母語話者的第三人稱代名詞使用傾向與容許度―以是否有性別相關訊息的觀點分析―陳嬿如(Chen Yenju)・頁 117–139