不「盡信書」之儒者─中井履軒的経書觀─
Confucian that does not necessarily believe in all classical writings: Perspective of Riken Nankai on classical writing
明道大學應用日語學系助理教授( Assistant Professor, MingDao University Depatment of Japanese studies)
摘要
日本江戶時代的代表儒者中井履軒,其對《孟子》的解釋,往往有出乎傳統儒者意表的見解。傳統的儒者認為亞聖孟子的言論,全都是萬古不變的金科玉律,對此,中井履軒表示否定的態度。
此外,履軒完全否定了在經學世界中不得不有條件認定存在的冤魂之類,對於『毛詩』、『尚書』的內容也有取捨選択,達到超越儒者侷限的学問境地。從中井履軒身上,可看到江戶中期的日本,不盲目信仰經書中的內容,而是依拠個人思想適當取捨経書意涵。擺脫前人的束縛,自由開展個人學問的姿態,讓人感受到近代來臨的腳步聲。
Abstract
There are aspects of interpretation on "Mencius" by Riken Nakai, who was the representative Confucian of the Edo Era in Japan, that would be difficult to conceive as a traditional Confucian. Proper Confucians are expected to accept all remarks made by the sage of the second order, Mencius, as axioms of immutable laws. Yet Riken evaluated the chapter on "all classical writings" as the "means" of Mencius.
Riken also completely rejected the idea that in the world of Confucianism the presence of evil must be acknowledged, even though in a limited sense. He was also selective with the contents of the "Book of Odes" and the "Shangshu", which set his scholarship as a Confucian apart from the rest. It is evident from Riken Nakai that in Japan of the mid Edo Era there was this practice of selecting classical writings as appropriate according to the individual ideology, rather than blindly believing everything in classical writing as given, as an object of worship. The stance of advancing their scholarship that is free, being released from the given restraints, was what turned out to be a faint sign of approaching modern era.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大日本語文研究
- ISSN
- 1609-8978
- 卷期
- 33期
- 出版
- 2017年06月
- 頁碼
- 149–176
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008860
同期目錄
- 女性冷硬派小說中的性與暴力-以桐野夏生《OUT》為例陳美瑤(Mei-Yao Chen)・頁 001–027
- 「問題文藝」與早稻田派 —探討與日本自然主義的關係—王憶雲(Wang, Yi-yun)・頁 029–048
- 「竹」的「斎宮」與「月」之「皇女」 ―『大和物語』的『竹取物語』引用―齋藤正志(Masashi Saito)・頁 049–063
- 《平家物語》〈うた〉與〈物語〉間的論述:以巻一「鹿谷」為中心楊錦昌(Yang, Chin-chang)・頁 065–79
- 德富蘇峰的視角與台灣的記憶 —以《臺灣遊記》為中心—黃翠娥(Tsui-O Huang)・頁 81–102
- 太宰治「清貧譚」試論 ―登場人物的改寫與同時代東亞情勢之關連―何資宜(Tzo-i Ho)・頁 103–126
- 日語外來語詞素「-コン」林慧君(Lin,Hui-jun)・頁 127–148
- 不「盡信書」之儒者─中井履軒的経書觀─黑田秀教(KURODA Hidenori)・頁 149–176