松本豐多《四書辨妄》批判服部宇之吉 ─《漢文大系‧四書》中看到的安井息軒之政治思想─
Matsumoto Toyota Shi-Syo Ben-Mou critcized Hattori Unokichi:the Yasui Sokken`s political theory in the Kan-Bun-Tai-Kei Shi-Syo
南榮科技大学應用日語系助理教授(Assistant Proffesor of the Department of Applied Japanese, NanJeon University of Science and Technology)
摘要
本稿的目的是作為安井息軒(1799-1876)的周邊研究之一環,分析息軒最晩年的嫡傳弟子松本豊多(1848?-?)透過《漢文大系四書辨妄》(1911年,嵩山房)批判了服部宇之吉(1867-1939)所校訂《漢文大系》第1冊(1909年,冨山房。收錄《大学說》、《中庸說》、《論語集說》、《孟子定本》)的內容,闡明安井息軒学派的政治思想的一端。
本文將豐多所批判分成了①校勘的問題、②「訓読」的問題、③訓詁的問題、④解釋的問題,加以分析之後,獲得了如下的結論。安井息軒的経典解釋方法是,首先根據古註,不能同意古註的時候再參考新的註釋,他本來不願意引用自己不採納的註釋(《論語集說》之書法),他解釋某本經書的時候,企圖和其他經書整合。另外息軒的政治思想中,「修身」與「治國」直接連接著,「理氣」並不介於君民之間。就息軒而言,「修身」意指實行〈曲禮〉等經書所記載的具體的動作具有了「德」(良心),「治國」是為政者為了改善人民的生活習慣,基於「德」(良心)規定嚴格的法律,徹底「嚴罰主義」之後才能使得人民的教化成功。值得注意的是,息軒認為為政者不用了解「禮」的意義,不用使得人民了解「法」的意義,只要自己遵守「禮」制且強迫人民遵守「法」制,自然能成功地陶冶性情。
另外本稿釐清松本豐多的著作及事蹟。
Abstract
This paper as a part of research on Yasui Sokken (安井息軒:1799-1876) who was the greatest Japanese Han scholar called “the compilation of the study of old Chinese documents in the Edo period” , analyze the “Shi-sho-ben-mou”(四書辨妄) written by his the last student Matsumoto Toyota(松本豊多:1848?-?) in 1991, and clarify the point of Sokken`s political theory. In this book, Toyota had harshly criticized Hattori Unokichi(服部宇之吉:1867-1939)and his “Kan-bun-tai-kei”(漢文大系) vol.1 which included Sokken`s “Shi-syo”(四書) for its annotaitons was not consistent with the Sokken`s really meaning.
In conclusion, Sokken thought the moral training (修身) was directly related to the regin(治國) , the “LI-Qi”(理氣) did not intervence between a ruler and his people.The moral training meaned a ruler gained fame as good-natured through the practice of the behaviour in “Qu-Li”(曲禮) , the regin meaned a ruler cured his people of bad habit through a heavy punishment which based on his good-will. He emphazed if only a ruler restraints himself and his people doing, he can cultivate their character.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大日本語文研究
- ISSN
- 1609-8978
- 卷期
- 30期
- 出版
- 2015年12月
- 頁碼
- 129–160
- 編號
- NTUEJ00008882
同期目錄
- 『今昔物語集』裡的犬的故事與中國文學陳明姿(Chen, Mung-tzu)・頁 1–26
- 藤村『異鄉人』中的繪畫 ─夏凡諾的〈貧窮的漁夫〉所發揮之機制─范淑文(Fan, Shu-wen)・頁 27–49
- 佐藤春夫〈霧社〉論 ー對於台灣原住民的雙重凝視ー橫路啟子(Yokoji, Keiko)・頁 51–69
- 『聽風的歌』中之兩義性 ー「孤立」與「關係建立」ー石川隆男(Ishikawa, Takao)・頁 71–96
- 台灣日語教師的教師自我效能與教學行為之研究 ー以大學日語教師調查為例ー盧錦姬(Lu, Jin-Ji);溫雅珺(Wen, Ya-Chun);王福順(Wang, Fu-shun)・頁 97–127
- 松本豐多《四書辨妄》批判服部宇之吉 ─《漢文大系‧四書》中看到的安井息軒之政治思想─青山大介(Aoyama, Daisuke)・頁 129–160