FTAs and Fragmentation of Trade Remedy Rules—Lessons Drawn from Experiences of Vietnam
Thi Truc Linh Phan: Ph.D. Candidate at the School of Law, Seoul National University in Seoul, Korea; Lecturer at the Faculty of Law, Foreign Trade University in Hanoi, Vietnam.
Jaemin Lee: Professor of Law at the School of Law, Seoul National University in Seoul, Korea.
摘要
Free trade agreements (hereinafter “FTA”) are vital to foster trade liberalization and investment facilitation across the territories of the contracting parties. Meanwhile, trade remedies become more critical as a legitimate means for the contracting parties to employ so as to protect their domestic industries. The problem, however, is that FTAs are different when it comes to trade remedy rules and procedures. As a result, having participated in FTAs, many countries now have fragmented rules and procedures for their trading partners depending on the contents of the FTAs, and accordingly, their domestic legal instruments on trade remedies are also fragmented. Frequently, FTA-specific rules and procedures are incorporated into the domestic legal system through guidance or regulation issued by administrative agencies rather than statutes by the legislature. This phenomenon of the fragmentation of trade remedy rules and procedures because of multiple FTA provisions and sprouting non-statute legal instruments is causing new challenges for many countries, particularly for developing countries with fewer human and financial resources. Vietnam has experienced the same situation. The challenges that Vietnam has encountered and the approaches Vietnam has taken to overcome them will provide important lessons for other countries.
Abstract
Free trade agreements (hereinafter “FTA”) are vital to foster trade liberalization and investment facilitation across the territories of the contracting parties. Meanwhile, trade remedies become more critical as a legitimate means for the contracting parties to employ so as to protect their domestic industries. The problem, however, is that FTAs are different when it comes to trade remedy rules and procedures. As a result, having participated in FTAs, many countries now have fragmented rules and procedures for their trading partners depending on the contents of the FTAs, and accordingly, their domestic legal instruments on trade remedies are also fragmented. Frequently, FTA-specific rules and procedures are incorporated into the domestic legal system through guidance or regulation issued by administrative agencies rather than statutes by the legislature. This phenomenon of the fragmentation of trade remedy rules and procedures because of multiple FTA provisions and sprouting non-statute legal instruments is causing new challenges for many countries, particularly for developing countries with fewer human and financial resources. Vietnam has experienced the same situation. The challenges that Vietnam has encountered and the approaches Vietnam has taken to overcome them will provide important lessons for other countries.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 20卷2期
- 出版
- 2025年09月
- 頁碼
- 269–313
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000009
同期目錄
- A Conversation with Robert HudecJose Manuel Alvarez Zárate・頁 249–267
- FTAs and Fragmentation of Trade Remedy Rules—Lessons Drawn from Experiences of VietnamThi Truc Linh Phan & Jaemin Lee・頁 269–313
- Regulating Aberration: Tapping into the Ordinary Course of Trade Test vis-à-vis State-Caused Distortions in CommerceXueji Su・頁 315–350
- A Third Way Forward: The Fate of BITs in the Internal Market and China’s ChoiceHongling Ning・頁 351–384
- Tangled Warfare in a Vicious Circle: A Quantitative Analysis on the WTO Safety Valve Measures and NetworkXia Luo・頁 385–427
- The Precautionary Principle as a General Principle of International Law and Global Health LawThanh Hải Đoàn・頁 429–485
- A Book Review on Chios Carmody "A Communitarian Theory of WTO Law" (Cambridge University Press, 2024)Shin-Yi Peng・頁 487–493