撰史憑誰定良窳?──試論「良史」的變與不變
On the Criteria of the “True Historian” in Chinese Historiography
國立臺灣大學歷史學系(Department of History, National Taiwan University)
摘要
自從孔子(551-479 B. C.)稱讚晉之董狐為良史之後,司馬遷(135-86 B. C.)、班固(32-92)、陳壽(233-297)以降,多有人被稱為具良史之才,之後,且有不少人士談論良史的品質與特色。清中葉的章學誠(1738-1801)及民初的梁啟超(1873-1929)也談良史,到底良史的具體標準是什麼?這些標準又是誰定的?經過兩千多年,良史的定義有無變化,而其變化的原因何在?
本文想就良史在各時代所代表的意義加以分析討論,旨在說明「良史」的標準有其變與常,常的是其基本的無懼真誠,而變的則恰恰呈現該時代及人物的文化特色與歷史意識。
Abstract
Since Confucius praised Dong Hu (董狐) of Jin as a “Liang Shi (True Historian)”, the Grand Historian Sima Qian (司馬遷, 135-86 B.C.), Ban Gu (班固, 32-92), Chen Shou (陳壽, 233-297) have been also referred to have the quality of Liang Shi. Later, more and more people discussed about the characteristic features and nature of this designation. This issue had been raised again during the mid-Qing by the famous historical philosopher Zhang Xuecheng (章學誠, 1738-1801) and later by Liang Qichao (梁啟超, 1873-1929) in the early 20th Century. What were the criteria worthy of the title “True Historian”? And who according to what principles made these criteria? Throughout the last two thousand years, had the criteria of Liang Shi changed over time? And if it did, then what were the causes behind these changes? This article tries to discuss the meaning of the Liang Shi in different periods respectively, indicating that there had been change and continuity regarding the criteria of being a True Historian. What remains constant is basically the fearlessness and honesty. The changing part, however, reflected the different cultural climates and historical consciousness of the people of the time.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 44期
- 出版
- 2009年12月
- 頁碼
- 001–041
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009344
同期目錄
- 撰史憑誰定良窳?──試論「良史」的變與不變古偉瀛(Wei-Ying Ku)・頁 001–041
- 齊梁士人的交遊──以任昉的社交網絡為中心的考察鄭雅如(Ya-Ju Cheng)・頁 043–091
- 從「完全之人」到「完全之平等」──劉師培的革命思想及其意涵楊貞德(Chen-Te Yang)・頁 093–152
- 德國在華軍事情報機關(1941-1945)陳郴(Chern Chen)・頁 153–194
- 評陳弱水著,《唐代的婦女文化與家庭生活》廖宜方(Yi-Fang Liao)・頁 195–204
- 評鮑曉鷗著,那瓜譯,《西班牙人的臺灣體驗(1626-1642):一項文藝復興時代的志業及其巴洛克的結局》楊宗霖(Zong-Lin Yang)・頁 205–218
- 評述Cynthia J. Brokaw, Commerce in Culture: The Sibao Book Trade in the Qing and Republican Periods(《文化貿易:清代至 民國時期四堡的書籍交易》)王一樵(I-Chiao Wang)・頁 219–229
- 附錄・頁 231–249