從「完全之人」到「完全之平等」──劉師培的革命思想及其意涵
From “Complete Person” to “Complete Equality”: Liu Shipei’s Revolutionary Pursuits and Their Implications
中央研究院中國文哲研究所(Institute of Chinese Literature and Philosophy, Academia Sinica)
摘要
本文以闡明劉師培的革命思想及其意涵為宗旨。劉師培在政治上的激烈主張和其間的快速轉變,早即引起諸多的關注和揣測。不過,劉氏更值得重視的意義,或另在他的思想的時代特徵和問題性。拙文因此從甲午戰後的「保種」、「保教」和「保國」三說談起,指出這三說逐漸走向以「保國」為尚的變化,以及劉師培在這般思想脈絡中,所提出「完全之人」和「完全之平等」兩項革命追求的意義。
「完全之人」是共和革命者劉師培的理想,側重個人人格的建立;「完全之平等」則是無政府主義者劉師培所期望建立的理想社會,強調制度的建構。梳理這兩項理念的內涵與轉變,將能指出劉師培如何擷取中西思想資源(包含中國傳統政治「公」與「均」的理念,和西方的盧梭《民約論》與無政府主義),來面對中國歷來所關切的「君權專制」和「貧富不均」兩大難題,與近代中國重新界定「國」(政治)和「教」(倫理)的需要。同時,這般討論也有助於彰顯「忠」之為政治倫理在清末民初所面臨的衝擊,近代中國「國家」、「政治」和「倫理」理念的變化,以及近代中國思想上政治和倫理權威危機的具體樣貌和深度。
Abstract
Liu Shipei was a modern Chinese revolutionary renowned for his fast shifting political commitments. Liu, however, has attracted historians’ attention mostly because, by looking into his intellectual trajectory, one can better understand the searches, visions, problems, and difficulties of his contemporaries. Following earlier historical explorations, this essay examines Liu’s revolutionary thought and its implications. My discussion begins with the calls for “protecting the race” (baozhung保種), “protecting the teachings” (baojiao保教) and “protecting the nation” (baoguo保國) after the Sino-Japanese war of 1894, which in the end culminated into emphasizing “protecting the nation” as the first priority. After situating Liu in this context of protecting and redefining the meanings of race, the teachings and the nation, I study in particular Liu’s ideas of “complete person” (wanquanzhiren 完全之人) and “complete equality” (wanquanzhipingdeng 完全之平等). The former signifies Liu’s republican revolutionary ideal personality, i.e., the embodiment of both public and private morality, whereas the latter, in contrast, stands for Liu’s anarchist ideal social arrangement and reflects his novel concern for society rather than the character of the citizen. Explicating the contents of these two ideals and the process by which the ideal of “complete person” gave way to “complete equality,” this essay has illuminated that Liu mobilized both Chinese and Western sources in answering traditional Chinese concerns against despotism and inequality as well as modern Chinese needs for redefining the nation (politics) and the teachings (ethics). In short, Liu first appealed to the traditional Chinese ideal of “publicness” and Rousseau’s idea of social contract for achieving the political pursuit of “publicness” and later connected the traditional Chinese ideal of equality to Western anarchism in order to realize the traditional Chinese economic pursuit of equality for all. By disclosing Liu’s revolutionary ideas and their implications, one could not only identify Liu’s historical significance but also understand the challenges for the idea of loyalty in modern China, the changes in the ideas of “nation,” “politics” and “ethics” in modern Chinese intellectual history, and the depth of the crisis of authority of modern Chinese political and ethical thinking.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 44期
- 出版
- 2009年12月
- 頁碼
- 093–152
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009346
同期目錄
- 撰史憑誰定良窳?──試論「良史」的變與不變古偉瀛(Wei-Ying Ku)・頁 001–041
- 齊梁士人的交遊──以任昉的社交網絡為中心的考察鄭雅如(Ya-Ju Cheng)・頁 043–091
- 從「完全之人」到「完全之平等」──劉師培的革命思想及其意涵楊貞德(Chen-Te Yang)・頁 093–152
- 德國在華軍事情報機關(1941-1945)陳郴(Chern Chen)・頁 153–194
- 評陳弱水著,《唐代的婦女文化與家庭生活》廖宜方(Yi-Fang Liao)・頁 195–204
- 評鮑曉鷗著,那瓜譯,《西班牙人的臺灣體驗(1626-1642):一項文藝復興時代的志業及其巴洛克的結局》楊宗霖(Zong-Lin Yang)・頁 205–218
- 評述Cynthia J. Brokaw, Commerce in Culture: The Sibao Book Trade in the Qing and Republican Periods(《文化貿易:清代至 民國時期四堡的書籍交易》)王一樵(I-Chiao Wang)・頁 219–229
- 附錄・頁 231–249