明治國家體制與臺灣──六三法之政治的展開
The Meiji State and Taiwan-The Political Extension of Law 63 Promulgated in 1896
國立臺灣大學歷史學系(Department of History, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本論文在研究日本領有臺灣之後,如何將臺灣這個新領土安置在其大日本帝國憲法的框架之內,並同時兼顧統治臺灣時的特殊需要。時間的斷限,設定於明治29年(1896)〈六三法〉成立,到明治39年(1906)〈三一法〉成立的十年間。透過觀察日本如何在毫無殖民地統治經驗之下,藉著外籍顧問提供意見,並在這些意見的基礎上形成制度設計,及其在政府、議會之間的折衝中政治性的展開。在這十年間,雖然六三法所代表的殖民地主義原則和委任立法的違憲爭議,不斷遭到帝國議會質疑,但明治政府一直透過政治手段護衛六三法。最後甚至企圖透過修憲,在憲法中明訂臺灣的統治由另外的法律規範,即一再地努力將臺灣實質地排除在日本國法域之外。明治39年,即使主張內地延長主義原則的原敬擔任國務大臣,其以內地延長主義為目標的法案也在帝國議會受挫,反而讓繼承六三法之殖民地主義原則的〈三一法〉通過了。可見日本外地統治的殖民地主義原則此時已經確立,其改變必須再等到第一次世界大戰時期了。
Abstract
This paper examines Japan’s displacement of Taiwan, a new colony, into the framework of the Constitution of the Great Japanese Empire after it acquired Taiwan; in the meantime, it also considers the necessity of special arrangements for ruling Taiwan. The time period focused on the 10 years from the passing of Law 63 in 1896 to the passing of Law 31 in 1906. The article analyzes how the Japanese, without any colony management experience, developed and designed colonial systems based on Westerners’ advice and suggestions, and further developed political supports through negotiations inside the government and congress. Within these ten years, though Law 63, which represented the principle of Colony Extension and the violation of Constitution, was frequently questioned by the Imperial Diet, the Meiji government consistently protected Law 63 through political manipulations. In the last stage, it tried to reform the Constitution to authorize a special legal system for ruling Taiwan. For these reasons, the Act claiming a principle of Motherland Extension proposed by the Minister Hara Takeshi was not accepted, while Law 31, which continued an approach of the colony extension principle in Law 63 was passed. Thus, the colony principle was formalized, and was not changed until the end of the World War I.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 37期
- 出版
- 2006年06月
- 頁碼
- 059–143
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009399
同期目錄
- 南宋政府的私鹽防治梁庚堯(Ken-Yao Liang)・頁 001–058
- 明治國家體制與臺灣──六三法之政治的展開吳密察(Mi-Cha Wu)・頁 059–143
- 江山如此多嬌──1930年代的西北旅行書寫與國族想像沈松僑(Sung-Chiao Shen)・頁 145–216
- 抗戰前中日「廣田三原則」談判(1935~1936)──著重其背景、緣起與議題之探討李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 217–265
- 專家與通識──章學誠的學術思路與錢穆的詮釋許松源(Song-Yuan Shu)・頁 267–300
- 亂世從政之地理指南──羅澤南手稿《皇輿要覽》初探范廣欣(Guang-Xin Fan)・頁 301–318
- 歷史課堂教學的新程式──故事、閱讀與書寫張元(Yuan Zhang)・頁 319–349
- 黃一農,《兩頭蛇-明末清初的第一代天主教徒》古偉瀛(Wei-Ying Ku)・頁 351–356
- 科學與想像之間──評克勞汀.柯亨,《長毛象的命運》楊彥彬(Yan-Bin Ya)・頁 357–370