日本機密檔案中的伍廷芳
Wu Tingfang as Seen through the Japanese Secret Archives
哈佛大學費正清東亞研究中心研究員、東京大學大學院地域文化研究客座教授(Associates in Research, Fairbank Center for East Asian Research, Harvard University);東京大學大學院總合文化研究科地域文化研究助教授(Associate Professor, Area Studies in Komaba, The Univerisity of Tokyo Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Department of Area Studies)
摘要
伍廷芳是晚清著名的外交家,是近代中國向西方尋求真理的代表人物之一。然而,以往的研究,忽視了伍氏與日本之關係。本文採用日本外交檔案中原始記錄,揭示了伍廷芳研究中被人們忽略的一個重要方面。早在甲午戰爭中,伍廷芳作為《馬關條約》談判的頭等參贊,開始與日本方面有較多接觸。回國後,伍氏又向日本駐天津領事荒川巳次及駐京公使林董,多次提供清廷上層不同政治派別對和戰的態度,以及彼此間的矛盾與裂痕等情報,並對中國前途悲觀失望,以為中國會四分五裂,走向滅亡。伍廷芳還試圖藉日本戰後之威力來恢復李鴻章在戰爭中失去的權力和地位。公然聲稱,如果李鴻章能繼續有所作為「實彼我之幸福,兩國之大利也」。爾後,伍廷芳由美國出使歸來,又再度向駐京公使內田康哉泄露清廷內部政要秘聞,揭露了清廷內部長期存在著一個親俄黨,聯芳即其代表人物,以及光緒皇帝生前之危險處境,並試圖要日本公使及夫人向慈禧進言,勸慈禧拔擢伍氏等到關鍵崗位等。日本檔案中所保留的這些情報在今天看來,似乎已是人們共知的情事,而在當時日本外交官卻對此類情報極為重視,他們都將伍氏談話認真整理後系統向外務大臣報告,然後,外務省又將它們大多呈送給總理大臣過目。本文具體分析了伍廷芳向日本提供情報的原因,主要是受李鴻章等人政策之影響,以及伍氏本人對封建制度的厭惡和對日本抱有不切實際的幻想所致。本文揭示日本機密檔案中這些罕為人知的史料,不是要否定其歷史功績,而是希望正確認識中國近代史上這個重要歷史人物。
Abstract
Wu Tingfang was a very famous diplomat in late Qing, was also one of pioneers seeking truth from the West. Earlier studies on him neglected Wu’s relationship with Japan. This article is written according to the original records in the Japanese Foreign Office Archives, and reveals one important
aspect which so far not known to the public. After the Sino-Japanese War, being the first attaché in the Chinese Negotiation Delegation, Wu began to have frequent contacts with the Japanese. Later Wu returned to China and paid visits to the Japanese Consulate-general in Tianjin, Kiji Arakawa, and the Minister, Tadasu Hayashi, many times, and reported to them about situation of the power struggle among the different cliques in the high level of the Qing bureaucracy. He also provided some information on the Qing attitudes toward war and peace. Wu also showed pessimism towards the future of China, thought China would split up and be eventually destroyed. Wu sought the help of post-War victorious Japan to restore Li Hongzhang’s power and status lost during the War. Wu even claimed publicly that if Li should regain his power, it would have “great happiness and benefits for both of our two countries.” Wu was later appointed as the Minister to the United States. After he returned, again he revealed to the Japanese Minister Yasuya Uchida on the information regarding the pro-Russia faction in the Qing Court and Lian Fang was a leader. He reported the precarious situation of the Guangxu Emperor. He also attempted to persuade the Japanese Minister and his wife to put in a good word for him in front of Empress Dowager Cixi and elevate Wu into high position… The information as revealed in the Japanese archives is well known today. But at that time the Japanese diplomats took it very seriously. They carefully sorted out and systematically presented to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. In turn, the Ministry of the Foreign Affairs presented most of the information to the Premier of Japan. This article specifically analyzes the reasons behind Wu’s providing information to the Japanese. It was mainly because Wu was influenced by Li Hongzhang’s policies, and Wu’s abhorrence toward the Chinese feudalistic system, together with his impractical fascination towards Japan. This article unearths those almost unheard-of materials from the Japanese secret archives, in the hope that, rather than denying Wu’s historical contribution, but understanding correctly this important figure in modern China.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 33期
- 出版
- 2004年06月
- 頁碼
- 215–259
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009444
同期目錄
- 文武糾結的困境──宋代的武舉與武學方震華(Cheng-Hua Fang)・頁 001–042
- 宋代的「車駕臨奠」皮慶生(Qing-Sheng Pi)・頁 043–069
- 聖人之書與天理的恆常性:朱子的經典詮釋之前提假設吳展良(Chan-Liang Wu)・頁 071–095
- 金代女真進士科制度的建立及其對女真政權的影響徐秉愉(Ping-Yu Hsu)・頁 097–132
- 萬髮俱齊:網巾與明代社會文化的幾個面向林麗月(Li-Yueh Lin)・頁 133–160
- 皇帝的最後一道命令──清代遺詔製作、皇權繼承與歷史書寫陳熙遠(His-Yuan Chen)・頁 161–213
- 日本機密檔案中的伍廷芳孔祥吉(Xiang-Ji Kong);村田雄二郎(Murata Yujiro)・頁 215–259
- 方豪神父與民國天主教會李東華(Tong-Hwa Lee)・頁 261–313
- 殖民地邊區的企業──日治時期東臺灣的會社及其企業家林玉茹(Yu-Ju Lin)・頁 315–363
- 激進主義、現代情境與中國無政府主義之崛起楊芳燕(Fang-Yen Yang)・頁 365–397
- 無政府主義概念史的分析王遠義(Yuan-Iee Wang)・頁 399–425
- 日本學界對中國無政府主義之評介安井伸介(Shinsuke Yasui)・頁 427–442
- 如何審視鏡像中國?評介《中國與歷史資本主義:漢學知識的系譜學》邱澎生(Peng-Sheng Chiu)・頁 443–455