天下興亡,「匹夫」之責?-明清鼎革中的夏家婦女
To Save the Nation is the Duty of "Men"?-The Women of the Hsia Family during the Ming-Ching Transition
國立臺灣大學歷史學研究所(Department of History, National Taiwan University)
摘要
前人對明清之際士人殉死現象的探討,大都著重在觀察男性士大夫的生死抉擇,而甚少關心女性在這場劇變中的際遇。松江夏家的男性成員全部在明清鼎革之際殉國,但對明朝忠心耿耿的夏家男性,並沒有要求夏家的女性從死,反而希望她們能夠彼此照顧,努力存活,因為他們和當時社會上大多數的人都認為,天下興亡乃是「匹夫」之責。和一般的印象不同,夏家婦女在國變之後,並不是以男性中心的妻妾婆媳關係來互相依存,而是由一個父系家庭拆解為數個以女性為中心的生活單位,並透過女性之間的關係,與其他的父系家庭結合成新的社會關係網絡。清人對夏家婦女的再現,多半著重在其守節撫孤的事蹟,但在抗戰以後,夏家故事的傳述者則越來越重視夏家婦女對抗清運動的支持和參與,顯示天下興亡「匹夫」之責的觀念,已經開始轉變。
Abstract
During the Ming-Ch'ing transition, all of the male members of the Hsia family in Sung Chang died because of their connection with the anti-Ch'ing movement. Though the male members were so loyal to the Ming dynasty, they did not ask their female family members to die with them or to take revenge for them, because they believed that to save the nation was the duty of "men". After losing their husband, sons and brothers with whom the daughters of different family names connected, the Hsia women no longer lived with their in-laws. Instead of preserving the broken patriarchal family, the Hsia wife, concubine, and daughter-in-law chose to live with their own daughter. The Hsia daughter and daughter-in-law of Hou family, Shu-chi, was the only Hsia woman to live with her in-laws. In fact, the cohabiting Hou widows had transformed their in-law relation into a religious sisterhood. For a long time, the main theme of the story of the Hsia women has been their chastity and hardship to preserve the offspring of the loyalist family. During the Sino-Japanese war in 1937-1945, writers began to emphasize the support and participation in the anti-Ch'ing movement of the Hsia women. It appears that the idea has changed, especially in the minds of the Nationalists in the Republican era: to save the country is no longer the duty only of men, but both of men and women.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 29期
- 出版
- 2002年06月
- 頁碼
- 063–085
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009489
同期目錄
- 王陽明「四句教」的三次辯難及其詮釋學義蘊陳立勝(Li-Sheng Chen)・頁 001–027
- 王畿與佛教彭國翔(Guo-Xiang Peng)・頁 029–061
- 天下興亡,「匹夫」之責?-明清鼎革中的夏家婦女孫慧敏(Huei-Min Sun)・頁 063–085
- 包容儒學、諸子與黃帝的國學:清季士人尋求民族認同象徵的努力羅志田(Zhi-Tian Luo)・頁 087–105
- 直覺與工具理性批判:梁漱溟對儒家經典的文化詮釋高瑞泉(Rui-Quan Gao)・頁 107–126
- 日本陽明學者中江藤樹與大鹽中齋對「孝」之解釋張崑將(Kun-Chiang Chang)・頁 127–167
- Time, Religion and History in IndiaHarbans Mukhia・頁 169–180
- 作為事件的徂徠學:思想史方法的再思考子安宣邦(Koyasu Nobukuni)・頁 181–188
- Making Sense of Time: Towards a Universal Typology of Conceptual Foundations of Historical ConsciousnessJörn Rüsen・頁 189–206
- 中西文化傳播的雙向互動與文化轉型:兼評張西平《中國與歐洲早期宗教和哲學交流史》王曉朝(Xiao-ChaoWang)・頁 207–222
- 評陳爽著《世家大族與北朝政治》趙立新(Li-Hsin Chao)・頁 223–234