包容儒學、諸子與黃帝的國學:清季士人尋求民族認同象徵的努力
The Rise of "National Learning": Confucianism, the Various Ancient Philosophers, and the Yellow Emperor in Chinese Intellectuals' Search for a Symbol of National Identity in the Late Qing
四川大學歷史系教授
摘要
庚子後士人對朝廷失去信任,乃試圖尋求一個可以「代表中國」而為全民族所認同的象徵,結果出現孔子紀年和黃帝紀年的競爭;同時,在國粹學派從中國學術源流中梳理「國粹」的嘗試中,因儒學定於一尊而落到邊緣的諸子學受到關注,子學與儒學也形成競爭局面。不過,這些努力的共同目標是因應中西之間的學戰,不論是從傳統中尋找還是乾脆「再造」一個象徵,都不能不具有開放性和包容性。結果形成一種「集各學之大成」的「國學」或「國魂」觀:它可以同時包容黃帝和孔子,既傳承了長期的學統,又提供了通過重新詮釋而再造屬於「民族國家」的新學術思想體系的空間。
Abstract
After the Boxer Uprising of 1900, many Chinese intellectuals lost confidence in the Qing government and searched for a symbol of national identity that could represent the Chinese nation. This resulted in a contest between two chronologies, one marking time from Confucius and the other from the Yellow Emperor. At the same time, the attempt of the “national studies” school to find a “national essence” in the larger traditional learning turned attention to the thought of the various ancient schools (zhuzi) that had been marginalized with the establishment of Confucian orthodoxy. This led to a struggle between the intellectual systems of the various (non-Confucian) schools and Confucianism. All these efforts were a response to the “cultural war” between China and the West. A symbol of China, regardless of whether it was to be found in tradition or simply “invented”, had thus to be open and all-inclusive. The result was a comprehensive intellectual amalgamation that included both the Yellow Emperor and Confucius. Such “national learning” or “national spirit” would not only inherit the long tradition of Chinese learning through reinterpretation of the past but also provide room for the re-creation of a new intellectual system appropriate to the modern nation-state.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 29期
- 出版
- 2002年06月
- 頁碼
- 087–105
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009490
同期目錄
- 王陽明「四句教」的三次辯難及其詮釋學義蘊陳立勝(Li-Sheng Chen)・頁 001–027
- 王畿與佛教彭國翔(Guo-Xiang Peng)・頁 029–061
- 天下興亡,「匹夫」之責?-明清鼎革中的夏家婦女孫慧敏(Huei-Min Sun)・頁 063–085
- 包容儒學、諸子與黃帝的國學:清季士人尋求民族認同象徵的努力羅志田(Zhi-Tian Luo)・頁 087–105
- 直覺與工具理性批判:梁漱溟對儒家經典的文化詮釋高瑞泉(Rui-Quan Gao)・頁 107–126
- 日本陽明學者中江藤樹與大鹽中齋對「孝」之解釋張崑將(Kun-Chiang Chang)・頁 127–167
- Time, Religion and History in IndiaHarbans Mukhia・頁 169–180
- 作為事件的徂徠學:思想史方法的再思考子安宣邦(Koyasu Nobukuni)・頁 181–188
- Making Sense of Time: Towards a Universal Typology of Conceptual Foundations of Historical ConsciousnessJörn Rüsen・頁 189–206
- 中西文化傳播的雙向互動與文化轉型:兼評張西平《中國與歐洲早期宗教和哲學交流史》王曉朝(Xiao-ChaoWang)・頁 207–222
- 評陳爽著《世家大族與北朝政治》趙立新(Li-Hsin Chao)・頁 223–234