From Accommodation to Territorial Expansion: The Transformation of Song Zhe-zong's Xi Xia Policy and Its Compatible Military Strategy
從妥協退讓到領土擴張:論宋哲宗朝對夏政策的轉變及其兼容的軍事戰略
香港中文大學歷史系(Department of History, The Chinese University of Hong Kong)
Abstract (Chinese)
本文檢討了宋哲宗朝對西夏的政策,特別關注其自妥協退讓到領土擴張的劇烈轉變。在傳統歷史上,元祐時期被視為兩次長期軍事衝突之間的小休,展現了政治上的保守主義和戰略防禦的重新施行。然而宋夏之間複雜的戰略互動,令宋朝不能只管按著國內利益來界定大戰略內容。本文認為黨派政治不足以充分解釋宋代對西夏政策的轉變。相反,攻略取向其實早已根植於元祐時代政治領袖的現實主義路線。經過一連串勝利,宋人重新評估其整體作戰能力,並制訂出戰略攻勢與戰術防禦的微妙組合。宋軍在攻略天都山的勝利,標誌著持續而連貫的軍事策略,是宋廷經歷劇烈政策變更而仍能獲得成功的關鍵。
Abstract
This paper examines the Xi Xia policy of the reign of Song Zhe-zong and pays special attention to the radical transformation of preference from accommodation to territorial expansion. In conventional history, the Yuan-you era was known as a short respite between two periods of bloodshed, which saw the revision of political conservatism and reinstatement of defensive strategy. However, the nascent complexity of strategic interaction between Song and Xi Xia prevented Kaifeng from defining its grand strategy simply because of domestic interests This paper argues that factional politics is not sufficient to explain the change of Song China’s Xi Xia policy. Rather, the aggressive preference of Kaifeng was rooted in the realist approach of the political leaders during the Yuan-you period. As a result of a series of victories, the Sung reevaluated its military capacity and capability and formulated a sophisticated combination of strategic initiative and tactical defense. The triumph of the Song Tian-du Mountain campaign suggests the continual and sustainable military efforts a key of success despite the radical change of foreign policy.
Keywords
- Journal
- Historical Inquiry of the Dept. History, NTU
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- Issue
- No. 28
- Published
- 2001-12
- Pages
- 093–126
- Record ID
- NTUEJ00009502
In this issue
- The "Interpretive Tensions" in the Hermeneutic Tradition of East Asian Confucianism黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・pp. 001–022
- Good and Highest Good: One Interpretive Dimension of Great Learning by Zhu Zi郭曉東(Xiao-Dong Guo)・pp. 023–049
- Meaning and Intention in the Understanding: A Comparison between Thu Xi and Schleiermacher潘德榮(De-Rong Pan)・pp. 051–067
- A Re-interpretation of The Annals of the Spring and Autumn and The Zuo Commentaries by Gu Yanwu古偉瀛(Wei-Ying Ku)・pp. 069–091
- From Accommodation to Territorial Expansion: The Transformation of Song Zhe-zong's Xi Xia Policy and Its Compatible Military Strategy曾瑞龍(Shui-Lung Tsang)・pp. 093–126
- Revisiting "the Kingdom of Daughters": Gender Discourse on Flowers in the Mirror from the Middle Qing李仁淵(Ren-Yuan Li)・pp. 127–156
- Gender Criticism and It's Uses in Sinological Studies孫康宜(Kang-I Sun Chang)・pp. 157–174
- "Shu Er Bu Zuo" and Its Interpretational Implications for the Lunyu: A New Interpretation of the Lunyu Implied by Its Organizational Structure蔡振豐(Chen-Feng Tsai)・pp. 175–192
- Mencius' Uses of the Classics: Contexts and Methods黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・pp. 193–205
- "Comprehensiveness" and "Confucians": Xunzi and Confucian Hermeneutics陳昭瑛(Chao-Ying Chen)・pp. 207–223
- Introduction黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・pp. 225–231
- New Perspectives on China's Modernity溝口雄三(Mizoguchi Yuzo)・pp. 233–242
- "World History" and Perspectives on Japan's Modernity子安宣邦(Koyasu Nobukuni)・pp. 243–248
- A View of Chinese Modernity王遠義(Yuan-Yi Wang)・pp. 249–274
- Inoue Tôru's Chûgoku no Sôzoku to Kokka no Reisei: Sôhô Shugi no Shiten kara no Bunseki水口拓壽(Minakuchi Takuju)・pp. 275–280