重訪「女兒國」:清中葉以來關於《鏡花緣》的性別論述
Revisiting "the Kingdom of Daughters": Gender Discourse on Flowers in the Mirror from the Middle Qing
國立臺灣大學歷史學系(Department of History, National Taiwan University)
摘要
由於胡適在五四時期的詮釋,李汝珍的小說《鏡花緣》長期以來被認為是古典文學中提倡女權的先驅,對傳統中國的婦女問題有所發見。本文欲從不同時代、不同位置的讀者對《鏡花緣》的閱讀中,瞭解這樣的性別論述如何透過對古典文本抱持現實關懷的詮釋中建構而成,並將其影響力延續至今。作者企圖從此文導引出來的問題是:中國近代女權論述的建構中隱含的兩種預設──本質化的「西方」與「傳統」,如何影響時人對歷史文獻的評估。此種基於時代關懷的論述方式具有很大的影響力,使得後來的讀者面對的不僅是文本本身,而更是與晚清與五四時期的讀者進行對話。
Abstract
Because of Hu Shi’s interpretation during the May-fourth era, Li Ruzhen’s novel, Flowers in the Mirror (Jing-hua Yuan), has been regarded as a forerunner of the advocacy of women’s rights in classical literature and as having discovered the problems of women’s plight in traditional China. This article attempts to look over the various readings of Flowers in the Mirror from the readers of different eras and positions, in order to realize how this gender discourse was constructed on the basis of the interpretation of classical texts with contemporary concerns, and has kept its effectiveness even now.
The main question the author intends to pursue in this article is: how do the two assumptions, the essentialist “western” and the essentialist “tradition”, underlying the construction of feminist discourse from late Qing to May-fourth era, impinge on our evaluation of historical documents. This kind of discourse, derived from their contemporary concern, has great effectiveness, and causes the subsequent readers, not only to face the text itself, but also to converse with the readers of May-fourth era and late Qing.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 28期
- 出版
- 2001年12月
- 頁碼
- 127–156
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009503
同期目錄
- 論東亞儒家經典詮釋傳統中的兩種張力黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 001–022
- 善與至善:論朱子對《大學》闡釋的一個向度郭曉東(Xiao-Dong Guo)・頁 023–049
- 理解中的原義與原意:朱熹與梅萊爾馬赫的理解觀之比較潘德榮(De-Rong Pan)・頁 051–067
- 顧炎武對《春秋》及《左傳》的詮釋古偉瀛(Wei-Ying Ku)・頁 069–091
- 從妥協退讓到領土擴張:論宋哲宗朝對夏政策的轉變及其兼容的軍事戰略曾瑞龍(Shui-Lung Tsang)・頁 093–126
- 重訪「女兒國」:清中葉以來關於《鏡花緣》的性別論述李仁淵(Ren-Yuan Li)・頁 127–156
- 西方性別理論在漢學研究中的運用和創新孫康宜(Kang-I Sun Chang)・頁 157–174
- 《論語》所隱含「述而不作」的詮釋面向蔡振豐(Chen-Feng Tsai)・頁 175–192
- 孟子運用經典的脈絡及其解經方法黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 193–205
- 「通」與「儒」:荀子的通變觀與經典詮釋問題陳昭瑛(Chao-Ying Chen)・頁 207–223
- 主編引言黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 225–231
- 俯瞰中國近代的新視角溝口雄三(Mizoguchi Yuzo)・頁 233–242
- 「世界史」和日本近代的觀點子安宣邦(Koyasu Nobukuni)・頁 243–248
- 對中國現代性的一種觀察王遠義(Yuan-Yi Wang)・頁 249–274
- 井上徹著《中國の宗族と國家の禮制:宗法主義の視點からの分析》讀記水口拓壽(Minakuchi Takuju)・頁 275–280