錢穆論清學史述評
Qian Mu's View of Qing Intellectual History
美國維吉尼亞州立大學歷史系
摘要
本文以錢著《中國近三百年學術史》為主,評述錢穆研究清代學術史的成果。錢氏寫作之前,已見梁啓超所撰同書名之作。比較兩書,可見兩人思想與學術之異同。大致而言,論清初學者,錢梁略同;論清中葉學者,錢惡樸學之鄙宋攻朱,頗多譏評,而梁則認為乾嘉考據,甚具實證主義精神而好之。至於晚清,經今文興,梁隨康有為之後,為此-運動的推動者和宣揚者,自道有啓蒙之功。然錢穆一本尊崇宋儒之心,以及信仰朱子之執著,痛詆今文改制說之荒謬,甚不恥康之剽竊與武斷,視之為清學覆亡的罪魁禍首。於此可見,錢著與梁著立異之處,要在意識型態的不同,尚可見漢宋門戶之見的遺影,並未能在思想史方法上,有所突破。他仍採傳統的學案體,故未能將各種議題展開來討論,學術思想從一時代到另一時代轉進的過程,因而難詳,更難能顯示時代的深層動力,也不足以細究學術思想之間的相互關係,以及對時代的實際影響。一部以現代思想史方法書寫的清代學術思想史,猶有待於來者。
Abstract
This paper is a critical appraisal of Qian Mu's study of Qing intellectual history, focusing on his well-known book entitled Zhongguo jinsanbainian xueshushi (A history of Qing scholarship during the recent three hundred years). Attention is given to several basic questions: What incentive did Qian Mu have in mind when he embarked on writing this history of Qing scholarship? How did he handle his sources? Did he argue reasonably and logically? What was the form of his historical exposition? Would his admission of anti-Manchu prejudice affect his thinking and interpretation on Qing scholars? Generally, would his study of Qing scholars represent a high-level craft as an intellectual historian? Qian's intellectual history basically follows the traditional xuean style of writing. Hence, it is mainly a collection of short intellectual biographies from Huang Zongxi to Kang Youwei with annotated commentaries. Each chapter begins with a brief biographical note before highlighting principal ideas and thoughts, showing little transition of ideas and thoughts from one period to another. In general, Qian's views of early Qing scholars had few, if any, differences from his predecessor, Liang Qichao, who had written the exactly same titled book. The interpretations of middle-period Qing scholars, however, show a sharp contrast between Qian and Liang, mainly because of Qian's strong preference for Neo-Confucianism. He showed virtually no tolerance for those who criticized Zhu Xi, whom he considered the greatest Confucian scholar next only to Confucius himself. On the other hand, Liang praised the empirical research of mid-Qing scholars, which he cherished as the source of modern Chinese scholarship. As for the late Qing period, Qian had no respect whatsoever to the rise of New-text Confucianism and condemned its application to political reform, which he denounced as arbitrary and farfetched. He thus held Kang Youwei in great contempt. In Qian's opinion, Kang's arbitrariness and inconsistency delivered such a fatal blow to traditional Chinese scholarship that later scholars would have to start all over again. On the contrary, as the principal disciple of Kang, Liang honored the New-text movement as the force that had enlightened a new generation of scholars. The different conclusions drawn from the studies of the same subject made manifest the contrast in personal background and ideology between the authors.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 26期
- 出版
- 2000年12月
- 頁碼
- 099–119
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009525
同期目錄
- 錢賓四史學中的「國史」觀:內涵、方法與意義黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 001–037
- 論錢賓四先生「中國文化特質」說之形成與其內涵戴景賢(Ching-hsien Tai)・頁 039–062
- 學問之入與出:錢賓四先生與理學吳展良(Chan-Liang Wu)・頁 063–098
- 錢穆論清學史述評汪榮祖(Young-Tsu Wong)・頁 099–119
- 錢穆與科學史學之離合關係1926~1950王晴佳(Q. Edward Wang)・頁 121–149
- 司馬遷之心──〈報任少卿書〉析論阮芝生(Chih-Sheng Juan)・頁 151–205
- 耆年冠帶-關於明代「壽官」的考察邱仲麟(Chung-Lin Ch'iu)・頁 207–262
- 書寫忠烈:明末夏允彝、夏完淳父子殉節故事的形成與流傳孫慧敏(Huei-Min Sun)・頁 263–307
- 由「不抵抗」到抵抗──國府因應「九‧一八」之決策過程與困境李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 309–349
- 「數目字管理」是洞見或是限制?黃仁宇「大歷史觀」下的明清市場與政府邱澎生(Peng-Sheng Chiu)・頁 351–376
- Carole Levin and Patricia A. Sullivan Eds. Political Rhetoric, Power and Renaissance Women林美香(May-Shine Lin)・頁 377–387