錢穆與科學史學之離合關係1926~1950
Qian Mu and Scientific History 1926~1950
美國羅文大學歷史系(Department of History, Rowan University)
摘要
自二十世紀以來,中國史學經歷了多次重大變遷。這些變遷的結果是,中國史家不斷分化組合,以意識型態和治史風格為分野,形成了不同的派別。大致說來,在二十世紀上半期,至少存在三大派別:科學史學派、傳統史學派和馬克思主義史學派。如果依治史的方法來看,又可分「史料」與「史觀」兩派。由於各種條件的變化,這些流派之間又不斷交叉融合、相互影響。本文以錢穆早期史學為例,探究錢穆與科學史學家,即「史料學派」之間的關係。作者指出,錢穆的早期學術生涯,受到科學史學家的影響,以「考史」成名。但由於抗戰的關係,則使他逐漸與科學史學分道揚鑣,改以「著史」為業,宣揚中華文化的傳統價值,使他以後成為一代「國史大師」。
Abstract
Historical writings in 20(superscript th) century China witnessed several major changes. These changes caused historians to form different schools in different time periods. In the first half of the 20(superscript th) century, for instance, there appeared three schools: the scientists, the traditionalists, and the Marxists. Or, from a different perspective, one found the antithesis of the "Historical Source School" and the "Historical Explanation School." There were also a great deal of exchange and interactions among these schools. Focusing on the early career of Qian Mu, this article examines Qian's association with the scientific historians, or the leading figures of the "Historical Source School." The author contends that during the 1920s and the early 1930s, Qian basically adopted the "scientific" approach to the study of history, applying textual criticism to historical sources. It was largely due to the increasing threat of Japan's invasion in China in the late 1930s that he began to embark on a different career path, which was characterized by and well known for its emphasis on the spirit of Chinese culture and the value of historical narratives.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 26期
- 出版
- 2000年12月
- 頁碼
- 121–149
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009526
同期目錄
- 錢賓四史學中的「國史」觀:內涵、方法與意義黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 001–037
- 論錢賓四先生「中國文化特質」說之形成與其內涵戴景賢(Ching-hsien Tai)・頁 039–062
- 學問之入與出:錢賓四先生與理學吳展良(Chan-Liang Wu)・頁 063–098
- 錢穆論清學史述評汪榮祖(Young-Tsu Wong)・頁 099–119
- 錢穆與科學史學之離合關係1926~1950王晴佳(Q. Edward Wang)・頁 121–149
- 司馬遷之心──〈報任少卿書〉析論阮芝生(Chih-Sheng Juan)・頁 151–205
- 耆年冠帶-關於明代「壽官」的考察邱仲麟(Chung-Lin Ch'iu)・頁 207–262
- 書寫忠烈:明末夏允彝、夏完淳父子殉節故事的形成與流傳孫慧敏(Huei-Min Sun)・頁 263–307
- 由「不抵抗」到抵抗──國府因應「九‧一八」之決策過程與困境李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 309–349
- 「數目字管理」是洞見或是限制?黃仁宇「大歷史觀」下的明清市場與政府邱澎生(Peng-Sheng Chiu)・頁 351–376
- Carole Levin and Patricia A. Sullivan Eds. Political Rhetoric, Power and Renaissance Women林美香(May-Shine Lin)・頁 377–387