「數目字管理」是洞見或是限制?黃仁宇「大歷史觀」下的明清市場與政府
On Professor Ray Huang's Thesis of "Mathematically Unmanageable" in Late Imperial China
中央研究院歷史語言研究所(Institute of History & Philology, Academia Sinica)
摘要
本文檢討黃仁宇所提「數目字管理」概念,文分兩節,第一節針對「數目字管理」概念的三大構成要素:經濟組織、法律體系、文化觀念,說明黃氏如何藉此分析明清中國「不能在數目字上管理」而十七世紀末年英國則「能夠在數目字上管理」。第二節透過學界對明清市場與政府關係的新理解,反省「數目字管理」概念的作用與限制。基本上,我同意黃氏所提「經濟組識、法律體系、文化觀念」三者對分析明清市場與政府關係演變的洞見,但是,黃氏未能細緻說明三者間的交互關連;同時,更因為預設「現代性」發展的普同方向,從也減弱了三者間可能存在的複雜互動。如何發展黃氏開創的業績?是值得繼續努力的學術事業。
Abstract
My review article analyses and evaluates the "mathematically manageable" thesis raised by Professor Ray Huang. He points out three components in this thesis: form of efficient economic organizations, innovation of effective judicial system, and cultural constructions of private properly. Only in England by the end of 17(superscript th) century, have these components have all met together, though it is more like a process in conjunction than a series of conscious movement. By contrast, as Huang asserts, economic and human resources cannot be divided into interchangeable pieces in China, that is why he called it the "mathematically unmanageable" state. After sketching out the above thesis, Ⅰ testify some of the shortcomings when applies it to China. In conclusion, I posit two facets about Professor Huang's thesis. One is that the economic-legal-cultural components are indeed potential factors when delving into market/government relations in Late Imperial China, albeit they still needed to be defined carefully. The other is the theoretic deficiency, as it presumes all "modern" countries converge in capitalism, ignoring the possibility of the "alternative modernity" entailed in the economic organizations, legal system, and cultural understandings and interrelations of Late Imperial China.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 26期
- 出版
- 2000年12月
- 頁碼
- 351–376
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009531
同期目錄
- 錢賓四史學中的「國史」觀:內涵、方法與意義黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 001–037
- 論錢賓四先生「中國文化特質」說之形成與其內涵戴景賢(Ching-hsien Tai)・頁 039–062
- 學問之入與出:錢賓四先生與理學吳展良(Chan-Liang Wu)・頁 063–098
- 錢穆論清學史述評汪榮祖(Young-Tsu Wong)・頁 099–119
- 錢穆與科學史學之離合關係1926~1950王晴佳(Q. Edward Wang)・頁 121–149
- 司馬遷之心──〈報任少卿書〉析論阮芝生(Chih-Sheng Juan)・頁 151–205
- 耆年冠帶-關於明代「壽官」的考察邱仲麟(Chung-Lin Ch'iu)・頁 207–262
- 書寫忠烈:明末夏允彝、夏完淳父子殉節故事的形成與流傳孫慧敏(Huei-Min Sun)・頁 263–307
- 由「不抵抗」到抵抗──國府因應「九‧一八」之決策過程與困境李君山(Chun-Shan Li)・頁 309–349
- 「數目字管理」是洞見或是限制?黃仁宇「大歷史觀」下的明清市場與政府邱澎生(Peng-Sheng Chiu)・頁 351–376
- Carole Levin and Patricia A. Sullivan Eds. Political Rhetoric, Power and Renaissance Women林美香(May-Shine Lin)・頁 377–387