史記秦楚之際月表論考
On 'the Chronological Table by Months from Qin to Chu' of Shiji
國立臺灣大學歷史學系(Department of History, National Taiwan University)
摘要
在《史記‧十表》中,記時單位最小、涵蓋時間也最短的是〈秦楚之際月表〉。此表是將秦二世元年七月至漢高帝五年(前209~202)間的大事按月編排,但其記時體例一直備受質疑。本文首先釐清其年月例,進而闡述此表的記事功能。〈月表〉的年月例分為三類:甲、紀正朔年月(4人,8%);乙、計月而數(28人,56%);丙、兼計年月(18人,36%,含隱性案例九人)。藉由從計月者中鉤稽出兼計年月的隱性案例,全表98%的案例皆獲得合理的解釋。甲例銜接住秦、漢兩朝的曆年,確立了時間的界碑;乙、丙則標示出群雄起事或封王的歲月多寡。初起抗秦的群雄多用乙例;而丙例除一人存疑外,若非領袖群倫如懷王、項羽之流,就是最終服屬漢廷的諸侯王。初起群雄,恰與歸漢之諸侯王代謝消長;故而計月者盡亡之時,即漢王朝一統之日。明白此例,當時天下分合推移的過程一覽可知。在記事功能方面,涉及這一時期的《史記》本紀、世家和列傳,極少標明事件發生的月分,許多關鍵資料都只記載在《月表》裏。本文以表文前半涉及秦、楚和項氏的三個部份為例,說明太史公以表來統攝全書相關紀傳的寫作手法。文末〈附錄〉則係表文辨證六則。
Abstract
The 'Chronological Table by Months from Qin to Chu' recorded major events that happened during the period from the Second Emperor of Qin (209B.C) to the establishment of the Han Dynasty (202B.C.). Of the Ten Tables of Shift, it is the table that covers the shortest period of time and uses the smallest unit of time. The rules governing its timing have not been correctly analyzed by any readers or historians, and have been criticized so severely that its significance and uses could not be estimated properly. By examining every case in this table, it becomes clear that there are three types of time-recording in all: 1. that using signs of the official calendar such as yuan-nian (元年) and jeng-yueh (正月); 2. that using the number of months since the rise of the characters; 3.that using the number of months as well as of years. In the light of above analysis, nearly all of the rules of time-recording can be recognized, and 98% of the cases can be explained logically. With the understanding of the rules and their characters, the readers of the Table can easily find the historical changes during that eight years. In addition, the Table also includes many important and special records. In conclusion, the Table is essential to understanding what actually happened in the history of Qin and Chu that cannot be found elsewhere.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 23期
- 出版
- 1999年06月
- 頁碼
- 093–121
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009558
同期目錄
- 論史記中的孔子與春秋阮芝生(Jy-Sheng Ruaan)・頁 001–059
- 張晏《史記》亡篇之說新檢討易平(Ping Yi)・頁 061–092
- 史記秦楚之際月表論考閻鴻中(Hung-Chung Yen)・頁 093–121
- 漢唐之間的女性醫療照顧者李貞德(Jen-Der Lee)・頁 123–156
- 讀僧叡〈小品經序〉周伯戡(Po-Kan Chou)・頁 157–198
- 隋唐使臣赴倭及其禮儀問題高明士(Ming-Shih Kao)・頁 199–238
- 嚴復早期的求道之旅──兼論傳統學術性格與思維方式的繼承與轉化吳展良(Chan-Liang Wu)・頁 239–278
- 中國方術史上的形影觀李建民(Jian-Min Li)・頁 279–300
- 考古學上所見秦帝國的形成與統一徐蘋芳(Ping-Fang Xu)・頁 301–336
- 漢長安城未央宮遺址出土骨簽瑣議李均明(Jun-Ming Li)・頁 337–347
- 宋代史學的特質及其影響王德毅(Teh-Yi Wang)・頁 349–373
- 史學之體用──槐聚說史闡論之一汪榮祖(Young-Tsu Wong)・頁 375–393
- 試論儒學的宗教性內涵黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 395–409
- 論環境史研究的源起、意義與迷思:以美國的論著爲例之探討曾華壁(Hua-Pi Tseng)・頁 411–444
- 影視史學:理論基礎及課程主旨的反思周樑楷(Liang-Kai Chou)・頁 445–470
- 評介梁其姿的《施善與教化:明清的慈善組織》李孝悌(Hsiao-Ti Li)・頁 471–479