史學之體用──槐聚說史闡論之一
The Substance and Function of Historiography: Studies in Qian Zhongshu's View of History, Part One
美國維吉尼亞州立大學歷史系
摘要
錢鍾書早已是成名的文學家,然而自《管錐編》出版之後,其博學更震驚學界。他所提供的中西資料與寶貴的創見,足令所有的文史哲以及社會科學學者享用不盡。本文為研究錢氏史觀五篇之一,專注於錢氏所舉中國傳統史學五例。前四例涉及歷史文章與史學求真,可謂史學之值;第五例則有關史學之用。然本文不僅僅是釋錢,更欲將錢氏所提出的史學問題,推而廣之,盡量說明。結論是歷史文章可美,歷史真相可求,歷史可得善用。
Abstract
Qian Zhongshu had long been recognized as a great literary critic and novelist before the 1979 publication of the monumental Pipe-Awl Books (Guanzhui Bian) called the attention of learned communities at home and abroad to his vast learning in both Chinese and Western cultural traditions. His amazing erudition and penetrating insight dazzled serious scholars across the boundaries of professional disciplines. Philosophers, historians, political scientists, sociologists, psychologists, writers, and linguists all draw inspiration from his rich references and judicious comments, which are full of wit, wisdom, and vision. This essay is one of five studies on Qian's view of history. Qian ferrets out five thoughtful principles that compose the substance and function of traditional Chinese historiography. The first four principles touch upon two vital historiographical questions, namely, the style of historical writing and to what extent history can be truthful. The fifth principle is about the use of history. This essay, however, not only just to expound on Qian's thoughts but also amplifies the issues he raises. The conclusion is that historical narration can be beautiful, history can be truthful, and the use of history can be good to humanity.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大歷史學報
- ISSN
- 1012-8514
- 卷期
- 23期
- 出版
- 1999年06月
- 頁碼
- 375–393
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009567
同期目錄
- 論史記中的孔子與春秋阮芝生(Jy-Sheng Ruaan)・頁 001–059
- 張晏《史記》亡篇之說新檢討易平(Ping Yi)・頁 061–092
- 史記秦楚之際月表論考閻鴻中(Hung-Chung Yen)・頁 093–121
- 漢唐之間的女性醫療照顧者李貞德(Jen-Der Lee)・頁 123–156
- 讀僧叡〈小品經序〉周伯戡(Po-Kan Chou)・頁 157–198
- 隋唐使臣赴倭及其禮儀問題高明士(Ming-Shih Kao)・頁 199–238
- 嚴復早期的求道之旅──兼論傳統學術性格與思維方式的繼承與轉化吳展良(Chan-Liang Wu)・頁 239–278
- 中國方術史上的形影觀李建民(Jian-Min Li)・頁 279–300
- 考古學上所見秦帝國的形成與統一徐蘋芳(Ping-Fang Xu)・頁 301–336
- 漢長安城未央宮遺址出土骨簽瑣議李均明(Jun-Ming Li)・頁 337–347
- 宋代史學的特質及其影響王德毅(Teh-Yi Wang)・頁 349–373
- 史學之體用──槐聚說史闡論之一汪榮祖(Young-Tsu Wong)・頁 375–393
- 試論儒學的宗教性內涵黃俊傑(Chun-Chieh Huang)・頁 395–409
- 論環境史研究的源起、意義與迷思:以美國的論著爲例之探討曾華壁(Hua-Pi Tseng)・頁 411–444
- 影視史學:理論基礎及課程主旨的反思周樑楷(Liang-Kai Chou)・頁 445–470
- 評介梁其姿的《施善與教化:明清的慈善組織》李孝悌(Hsiao-Ti Li)・頁 471–479