我思故我在:論精神醫療 社會工作者的知識論思辨能力
I Think, Therefore I am: Developing the Competence for Epistemological Thinking for Psychiatric Social Workers
加拿大多倫多大學社會工作研究所博士生
- 類型
- 研究紀要
- 卷期
- 30期
- 出版
- 2014年12月
- 頁碼
- 187–226
- 編號
- NTUEJ00009897
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
受到專業建制化的思潮影響,精神醫療社會工作常將後實證主義當作
是學術研究與臨床實務的金科玉律。但隨著社會環境日趨複雜多變,加上
知識體系的多元蓬勃發展,本研究認為,精神醫療社會工作員應培養「知
識論思辨能力」─即分析、批判及整合多元知識的能力,才能善盡專業
職責,並取得專業主體性。知識論是從典範的層次來討論「知識的理論」,
其內涵包括知識的本質、取得、應用與限制,目前西方國家的文獻多將知
識論典範概略地區分為後實證主義、建構主義與批判理論,而全人取向則
源自於華人文化。為具體示範如何應用知識論的思辨能力,本研究以精神
醫療社會工作員協助憂鬱個案為討論脈絡,從上述四個典範來進行相關文
獻的回顧後,分別從憂鬱本質、社工角色、理論觀點、實務取向,以及社
工倫理原則來進行知識論分析。結論指出:上述四套知識論典範皆與精神
醫療社會工作實務密切相關,社工員要多方學習知識論視角,不應偏廢或
獨厚;知識論思辨能力也應成為社會工作教育的目標,如此社會工作才能
在專業社群中取得獨特位置。
Abstract
Following the movement toward professional institutionalization, social
work in the contemporary era tends to uncritically endorse post-positivism in
research and practice with the attempt togain societal recognition as real pro-fessionals. However, in the context of a rapidly and enormously changing so-ciety, along with an increasingly diversified practical knowledge, the author of
this article argues for the building ofthe competence of social workers for
epistemological thinking—an ability to analyze, critique, and synthesize
knowledge—as essential to fully serve the mission of the profession, and, more
importantly, to establish a professionaldistinctive space. An epistemological
paradigm contains a set of statements with respect to the nature, assumptions,
applications, and limitations of knowledge. Four epistemological paradigms have
been delineated in the existing literature including positivism, post-positivism,
constructivism, and critical theory. In addition, the holistic approach, which is
rooted in Chinese philosophy, has been a widely practiced paradigm in tChinese context. To demonstrate the competence for epistemological thinking,
this article used these four paradigms to synthesize and structure the literature
in relation to depression, a significantissue that has been extensively ad-dressed by psychiatric social workers. As a summary table is made to situate
knowledge within the four paradigms, it becomes evident that knowledge de-veloped in accordance with the four epistemological paradigms is relevant for,
and should be integrated into, social work practice. As such, this article sug-gests that rather than being sorely attached to a particular epistemological pa-radigm, social workers need to develop a comprehensive familiarity with the
various epistemological approaches in order to be responsive to the clients’
wide range of needs. By utilizing the epistemological analysis model ex-pounded in this article, it is hoped that epistemological thinking will be incor-porated into social work education and training.