臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

Risk Assessment Review Under the WTO Disputes Settlement System

Tsai-fang Chen

National Chiao Tung University

類型
論文
卷期
14卷2期
出版
2019年03月
頁碼
445–469
編號
NTUEJ00000099
僅書目本篇只提供書目資料,資料庫沒有電子全文。

需要全文時,可以向出版單位洽詢,聯絡方式見期刊資訊。

摘要

Regulations inspecting and restricting imported goods are important tools for any modern nation to protect the health of its citizens and of the living organisms within its borders. In order to prevent nations from using these tools to accomplish protectionist goals, and to further minimize unnecessary barriers to trade, the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) requires such measures to be based on a risk assessment conforming to scientific principles. This paper focuses on the review standard adopted by WTO adjudicating bodies when reviewing the consistency with such risk assessment with the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures. The standard of review employed by earlier WTO panels in their reviewing of Member’s risk assessment is, or is at least very close to, a de novo one. In order to correct previous trends, the Appellate Body in the Hormone Suspension case indicated that a proper standard of review requires the panel scrutinizing such a measure not to conduct its own risk assessment nor to make its own scientific judgment, but simply to ensure that the assessment was conducted according to the requirements of the relevant legal provisions. It raises hope towards a deferential standard of review regarding risk assessment. However, the Appellate Body Report of Australia — Apples, upon close examination, seems to upset such hope for meaningful deference through standards of review in such WTO dispute settlement proceedings. This is because the intensity of review, that is, the level of rigidity for the panel’s scrutiny adopted by the Appellate Body, could not actually deliver the deference warranted in this situation. This standard of review seems to be heavily influenced by the practice in trade remedy cases, despite the significant difference between them. A reform in this regard is warranted.

Abstract

Regulations inspecting and restricting imported goods are important tools for any modern nation to protect the health of its citizens and of the living organisms within its borders. In order to prevent nations from using these tools to accomplish protectionist goals, and to further minimize unnecessary barriers to trade, the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) requires such measures to be based on a risk assessment conforming to scientific principles. This paper focuses on the review standard adopted by WTO adjudicating bodies when reviewing the consistency with such risk assessment with the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures. The standard of review employed by earlier WTO panels in their reviewing of Member’s risk assessment is, or is at least very close to, a de novo one. In order to correct previous trends, the Appellate Body in the Hormone Suspension case indicated that a proper standard of review requires the panel scrutinizing such a measure not to conduct its own risk assessment nor to make its own scientific judgment, but simply to ensure that the assessment was conducted according to the requirements of the relevant legal provisions. It raises hope towards a deferential standard of review regarding risk assessment. However, the Appellate Body Report of Australia — Apples, upon close examination, seems to upset such hope for meaningful deference through standards of review in such WTO dispute settlement proceedings. This is because the intensity of review, that is, the level of rigidity for the panel’s scrutiny adopted by the Appellate Body, could not actually deliver the deference warranted in this situation. This standard of review seems to be heavily influenced by the practice in trade remedy cases, despite the significant difference between them. A reform in this regard is warranted.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明